Going off
@Lord Caedus' brilliant "Canada-wank" thing, I'm doing
Three's A Crowd in that world
25: William McKinley (Republican-Ohio) 1897-1901
1896: def. Joseph C. S. Blackburn (Democratic-Kentucky) and
Sylvester Pennoyer (Populist-Oregon) John Calhoun Bell (Populist-Colorado)
1900: def. Thomas E. Watson (Populist-Georgia) and Simon B. Buckner (Democratic-Kentucky)
Ooh, turns out Pennoyer would have been Canadian there. Replaced him with Bell
26: Theodore Roosevelt (Republican-New York) 1901-1909
1904: def. Thomas E. Watson (Populist-Georgia), William Randolph Hearst (Democratic-New York) and Alton B. Parker (Ind. Dem.-New York)
27: William Howard Taft (Republican-Ohio) 1909-1913
1908: def. William Jennings Bryan (Populist-Nebraska) and William Randolph Hearst (Democratic-New York)
28: Oscar Underwood (Populist-Alabama) 1913-1921
1912: def. William Randolph Hearst (Democratic-New York), William Howard Taft (Republican-Ohio) and Julius Wayland (Socialist-Kansas)
1916: def. Charles Evans Hughes (Republican-New York) and C. E. Russell (Democratic/Socialist-Iowa)
I know, boring. It'll pick up soon
29: Leonard Wood (Republican-New Hampshire) 1913-1921 29: Calvin Coolidge (Republican-Massachusetts) 1921-1929
1920: def. William Randolph Hearst (Democratic/Socialist-New York) and William H. Murray (Populist-Oklahoma)
1924: def. Fiorello La Guardia (Democratic-New York) and William Gibbs McAdoo (Populist-California)
Ooh here we go. Wood was New Hampshirean born and bred, so he's Canadian. In ATL, Coolidge is president for the 1920s, so Hoover...
30: Herbert Hoover (Republican-California) 1927-1933 1929-1933
1928: def. Cordell Hull (Populist-Tennessee) and Seymour Stedman (Democratic-Illinois)
Assumes power later than he did in ATL [and at the same time as OTL]
31: Huey Long (Populist-Louisiana) 1933-1941
1932: def. Upton Sinclair (Democratic-California) and Herbert Hoover (Republican-California)
1936: def. Frank Knox (Republican-Illinois) and
Lynn Frazier (Democratic/NPL-North Dakota) Norman Thomas (Democratic-Ohio)
Frazier was from North Dakota, which... Canadian there. Got another socialist to replace him
32: Franklin D. Roosevelt (National Union-New York) 1941-1945*
1940: def. Huey Long (Populist-Louisiana)
1944: def.
Charles Lindbergh (Populist-Michigan) Hamilton Fish III (Ind.-New Jersey) and
Earl Long ("Southern" Populist-Louisiana)
Ah. Now we get to a juicy bit. Lucky Lindy was basically the Populists' only choice of an unifying force, and the person who they rallied behind to stop the draft of Hamilton Fish III, a loud isolationist Republican who opposed the National Union and FDR's pro-war beliefs. In ATL...
33: Henry A. Wallace (National Union, then Democratic/NPL-Iowa) 1945-1953
1948: def.
Harold Stassen (Republican-Minnesota) Thomas Dewey (Republican-New York) and Richard Russell (Populist-Georgia)
Stassen is out, and I chose to be boring and put Dewey in, just so he would fritter it like OTL
34: Dwight D. Eisenhower (Republican-Kansas/Pennsylvania) 1953-1961
1952: def. Estes Kefauver (Populist-Tennessee) and Henry A. Wallace (Democratic/NPL-Iowa)
1956: def. John Sparkman (Populist-Alabama) and
Glen H. Taylor (Democratic/NPL-Idaho) Claude Pepper (Democratic-Florida)
Okay, this requires a bit of an explanation. The National Union Party allowed many Southern pro-war Populists to run as "National Union" against Populists, and a lot of them fell back into the fold. But some chose to be Democrats instead and support Wallace. They didn't last long after 1948, but second on President Wallace's running-mate list was Senator Claude Pepper of Florida. In "OTL" he chose Taylor, but without Taylor [he being Canadian] Pepper would have been chosen, and thus Pepper would have been high in the Democratic Party of the 50s just like Taylor was
35: Lyndon B. Johnson (Populist-Texas) 1961-1969
1960: def. Richard Nixon (Republican-California) and
Mike Mansfield (Democratic/NPL-Montana) Frank Lausche (Democratic-Ohio)
1964: def. Barry Goldwater (Republican-Arizona) and Michael Harrington (Democratic-New York)
Now, Lausche is more moderate for this Democratic Party yes. But remember exactly what coalition this party sprang out of. Party machines and the "ethnic vote". Lausche would doubtlessly be good at turning them out
36: Richard Nixon (Republican-California) 1969-1974 1975
1968: def. George Wallace (Populist-Alabama) and
Eugene McCarthy (Farmer-Labor-Minnesota) Vance Hartke (Democratic-Indiana)
1972: def.
George McGovern (Democratic/NPL-South Dakota) Harold Hughes (Democratic/NPL-Iowa) and George Smathers (Populist-Florida)
Alright, seems that I had like, a row of six Dem nominees from there-Canadian states. My bad. But yeah, Hartke was probably McCarthy's closest challenger while Hughes was likely the big front-runner but chose to endorse McGovern instead, cementing him as a big What-If
Due to Muskie being from Canada, LBJ sends the documents instead to Senator Ted Kennedy, who isn't as efficient as Muskie was, buying Nixon more time, and in the end, averting his suicide. He just instead humiliatingly resigned
37: John Connally (Republican-Texas) 1975-1977 1976
Since Nixon's suicide was a major part in the refusal of Congress to tackle Connally when he was scandalous, well, there he's impeached and removed before the election. Fun butterflies! ^^
38: Carl Albert (Populist-Oklahoma) 1976-1981
1976: def.
Frank Church (Democratic/NPL-Idaho) Cesar Chavez (Democratic-New Mexico) and
Nelson Rockefeller (Republican-New York)
Due to Connally being removed, Rockefeller's campaign against him succeeds and he wins the nomination. Still loses badly, but
better. Also, due to no Frank Church, Cesar Chavez's grassroots insurgent labor union campaign succeeds in winning the nomination[
39: Robert Redford (Democratic-California) 1981-1989
1980: def. George Bush (Republican-Connecticut) and
Dale Bumpers (Populist-Arkansas)
1984: def.
Jay Hammond (Republican-Alaska) Kit Bond (Republican-Missouri) and Fob James (Populist-Alabama)
Well, due to Carl Albert feeling too old to run in 80, Dale Bumpers gets the nod. And Kit Bond was probably the rival to Hammond in the primary
40: Lee Iacocca (Republican-Michigan) 1989-1993 40: John Heinz (Republican-Pennsylvania) 1989-1993
1988: def. Mario Cuomo (Democratic-New York) and Richard Riley (Populist-South Carolina)
The 1988 GOP ticket was really more of an unity ticket between the victorious Iacocca and the loser Heinz. Without Iacocca...
41: Bill Clinton (Populist-Arkansas) 1993-2001
1992: def. Donald Trump (Ind.-New York), Tom Harkin (Democratic/NPL-Iowa) and
John Heinz (Republican-Pennsylvania)
1996: def. Arlen Specter (Republican-Pennsylvania) and Jerry Brown (Democratic-California)
Bill is still his backstabbing self here, and the only change is that Heinz was the president he backstabbed
42: Joe Lieberman (Republican-Connecticut) 2001-2009
2000: def. Al Gore (Populist-Tennessee) and Dennis Kucinich (Democratic-Ohio)
2004: def.
Bernie Sanders (Democratic-Vermont) Ron Dellums (Democratic-California) and Rick Perry (Populist-Texas)
Basically the only name that changes is that Bernie, who still goes up to Vermont here, is replaced with Ron Dellums who there probably was the frontrunner until Bernie leapt him in the polling and whatnot
43: Warren Beatty (Democratic-California) 2009-2017
2008: def. John McCain (Republican-Arizona) and Rick Santorum (Populist-Pennsylvania)
2012: def. Lincoln Chafee (Republican-Rhode Island) and
Sarah Palin (Homesteader-Alaska) Foster Campbell (Populist-Louisiana)
Campbell is basically the main opposition to Palin in the primaries, and why she chose Carter as her running mate. In ATL, he wins[/S][/S]
Beatty would pick someone else to replace Weiner in 2012...
44: Marco Rubio (Populist-Florida) 2017-
2016: def.
Amy Klobuchar (Farmer-Labor-Minnesota) Wendy Davis (Democratic-Texas) and Bill Haslam (Republican-Tennessee)
The person Beatty picked in BiggerCanada!TAC would be Governor Wendy Davis of Texas, who would go on to lose the 2016 election[/S][/S]
And there you have it. Broadly what the BiggerCanada!TAC would look like