• Hi Guest!

    The costs of running this forum are covered by Sea Lion Press. If you'd like to help support the company and the forum, visit patreon.com/sealionpress

Scenes We'd Like To See: Alternate Movies, Television & Other Pop Culture Miscellanea

Noncanon is a colloquial term originating from Britain during the Windsor Regency, referring to serialised fiction producing during the 1941-43 occupation. As part of the attempt to show order had 'been restored', the Nazis and their collaborators forced writers & artists to make 'approved' versions of popular fiction, either their own creations or taking over for an exiled/deceased figure. After the liberation, these versions were disowned and ignored - "struck from the canon," as Agatha Christie said. Until the 1980s, there wasn't even a limited reprint.

Notable noncanonical takes include:

- Poirot as a willing agent of the occupational police, tracking down communist and Jewish saboteurs in Blind Man's Bluff and Horror at the Docks. (The first Regency book, Five Little Pigs, explicitly said Poirot had spent the occupation in the Dartmoor camps)

- Desperate Dan now helping stop the dastardly Americans and their plans for Europe, which in 1943 showed him fighting ever more elaborate Allied war machines coming out of Ireland. (The first strip after Dudley Watkins returned from exile had Dan beating up his "evil twin brother")

- Bulldog Drummond and his Black Gang continued to fight the dastardly Carl Petersen and his communist plots, now an official branch of the state to preserve King and Country. (An unsuccessful post-occupation followup tried to show Drummond and the Black Gang as rebels against the Germans)

- Unauthorised comics of Superman, now living in Germany - the last son of an Ayran planet and trying to recreate the lost world here. (Alan Moore would craft an Annual in the early 1980s where Superman is trapped in a nightmare of a world where he is a Nazi)
 
Noncanon is a colloquial term originating from Britain during the Windsor Regency, referring to serialised fiction producing during the 1941-43 occupation. As part of the attempt to show order had 'been restored', the Nazis and their collaborators forced writers & artists to make 'approved' versions of popular fiction, either their own creations or taking over for an exiled/deceased figure. After the liberation, these versions were disowned and ignored - "struck from the canon," as Agatha Christie said. Until the 1980s, there wasn't even a limited reprint.

Notable noncanonical takes include:

- Poirot as a willing agent of the occupational police, tracking down communist and Jewish saboteurs in Blind Man's Bluff and Horror at the Docks. (The first Regency book, Five Little Pigs, explicitly said Poirot had spent the occupation in the Dartmoor camps)

You just know in this TL there's at least one pastiche which pits the Basil Rathbone propaganda movie Holmes against Hercule Poirot, Agent of the Boche.
 
Been encountering a bit of DC history in some otherwise unrelated projects and it's got me thinking about that time Marvel nearly bought DC in the 1980s. To be specific, a Time-Warner executive (Bill Sarnoff, the same executive who had originally purchased DC for WB's parent company in the 1970s) reached out to Marvel to enquire whether they would be interested in licencing the DC characters as a comics imprint, with film & TV rights remaining with Time-Warner.

DC was in a bit of bother during the early 1980s, declining sales compared to their biggest competitor. Ironically, Marvel themselves had started out having their characters distributed by DC's predecessor National Comics. More ironically, Marvel themselves had come close to shutting up shop in the mid-70s before the Star Wars licence saved them. Anyway, Marvel President Jim Galton wasn't keen at first and had to be convinced by writers that there was merit to the characters but DC editorial was wasting them.

The deal got as far as Marvel's then editor Jim Shooter preparing for a launch of six titles (Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Teen Titans, Justice League, and Legion of Super Heroes) but when word got out many people balked at the idea. Plenty of DC writers had worked at Marvel and did not want to go back, or lose their jobs either, so ideas were thrown out. Third-party publishers were more worried about Marvel monopolising the comics industry and one even filed an antitrust lawsuit that went against DC/Marvel.

What if it hadn't? I think that court decision more than anything the DC writers through out kept the merger from happening. The US legal system goes back and forth on antitrust decisions, especially pertaining to entertainment, and since I can't find much info on First Comics actual lawsuit it might indicate that neither DC or Marvel appealed it. What if the decision had gone the other way, or the bigger companies had appealed?

On the DC front there is probably no "Crisis on Infinite Earths", The Dark Knight Returns or Watchmen. The sale not going through actually led to a renaissance in the company and during the 1990s they were arguably the bigger of the two major US comics companies. Probably not going to happen if the DC characters are being published under Marvel imprint. Are the characters integrated into the wider Marvel universe, or do they remain their own separate facet of the multiverse? My comics knowledge isn't enough to make any real speculation on what would have happened, but looking to other industries I wonder what the reactions from fans and the business would be.

Plenty of people in the industry, and many more fans, probably just won't accept the new DC published by Marvel. Do any other smaller third party competitors get a boost from an influx of creative talent? They would still be a long distant second but the days of DC suing their competition out of business are long gone. Would a new organisation emerge in short order? I note Dark Horse Comics launched around the same time as the merger would have been happening. And what does Marvel Comics do with a practical monopoly over the US comics industry? Can they make it work, or are they doomed to stagnation the way WWF/E were after buying their competition in the early 00s?
 
Been encountering a bit of DC history in some otherwise unrelated projects and it's got me thinking about that time Marvel nearly bought DC in the 1980s.

That's a fascinating one (covered it for Comics of Infinite Earths because how could I not?), huge scope for the US industry - also means John Byrne does Man of Steel a few years early as he was knocking on Jim Shooter's door the instant he heard of the deal.

One fun thing is Shooter's take on this (and also how he's writing about it in the contemporary memos) smacks of 'yeah DC's just a minor problem and we can do better cos they suck', but he also wants to do Teen Titans because that's a new major hit at the time. Printing the legend and all
 
That's a fascinating one (covered it for Comics of Infinite Earths because how could I not?), huge scope for the US industry - also means John Byrne does Man of Steel a few years early as he was knocking on Jim Shooter's door the instant he heard of the deal.

One fun thing is Shooter's take on this (and also how he's writing about it in the contemporary memos) smacks of 'yeah DC's just a minor problem and we can do better cos they suck', but he also wants to do Teen Titans because that's a new major hit at the time. Printing the legend and all
Yeah Teen Titans and Legion of the Super Heroes stood out amongst the six titles they wanted to kick off the new imprint.

One thing I did look up was Legion of Super Heroes since I wasn't familiar with the group at all. I saw that when the companies did Amalgam in the 1990s they were combined with the Guardians of the Galaxy. Since the Guardians were only brought back in the late 1980s by Tom DeFalco reacting to the popularity of TNG, it's possible that the group is never revived if they already have a DC group that can fit the niche.

Also, if Time-Warner retains their rights for the DC characters in film/television I wonder if they might also try to buy up the film/television rights to the Marvel characters that are available.
 
The Mighty Avengers was a cartoon based on the Marvel Comics superhero team of the same name. Although controversial among comic fans at the time for aging down most of the cast to their teens,side-lining Captain America to guest status(as played by Puddy star Patrick Warburton) , and inspiring the Time Rewritten event which is responsible for a lot of unpopular changes (such as ending Spider-Man's marriage). It was very popular and aired for five seasons. Loosely based on the Kurt Busiek,Roy Thomas, and Steve Englehart runs. The seven main characters are Iron Man (Mike Erwin), the scion of the Stark industrial family equipped with a high tech suit of armor; Hank Pym (Ben Diskin), a super intelligent juvenile scientist specializing in insects and size changing physics; Wasp (Tara Strong), a shrinking teen socialite; Thor (Matthew Wolf), a young Nordic demigod exiled to Earth; Hawkeye (Yuri Lowenthal), a expert archer with a chip on his shoulder; Scarlet Witch (Grey DeLisle): the witch daughter of the mutant radical Magneto (Christopher Judge); and Vision (Phil LaMarr), a robot built by the megalomaniacal Ultron(Tom Kaine) who turned on its creator. They're headquartered in Avengers Mansion in New York CIty which is tended to by Edwin Javis (Mark Williams). The first season deals with the team forming and combating supervillain threats secretly masterminded by Thor's half-brother, Loki (Rick Gomez). The second season introduces extremely obstructive government agent Henry Gyrich (Jim Ward),Hank Pym adapting the Yellowjacket persona because of his jealousy towards Iron Man,suspicion that the Wasp doesn't love him,and guilt over creating Ultron; this led to Hawkeye temporarily becoming Goliath. The third season focuses on the team battling the time traveling conquer Kang (Kevin Michael Richardson) and Justice League parody Squadron Supreme with the help of Kang's older form, Immortus while various guest stars form a west coast Avengers team. The fourth season is an adaption of the Thunderbolts story line where a group of supervillains led by The Taskmaster (Steve Blum) pretend to be heroes. For the final season, the Avengers go to space to find the Infinity Stones before the despotic Thanos can.
 
Sitting here reading the thread, I'd be curious as to an ATL where The Simpsons failed to catch on for whatever reason - maybe lasting a season or two. The effects on television animation up to the present would be tremendous.
Yes, it has proven to be perhaps ahead of Nostradamus in predicting the future accurately.
 
List of Star Trek: The Next Generation cast members

Season 1: Patrick Stewart, Jonathan Frakes, LeVar Buton, Denise Crosby, Michael Dorn, Gates McFadden, Marina Sirtis, Brent Spiner, Wil Wheaton
Season 2: Patrick Stewart, Jonathan Frakes, LeVar Burton, Michael Dorn, Marina Sirtis, Brent Spiner, Wil Wheaton
Season 3: Patrick Stewart, Jonathan Frakes, LeVar Burton, Michael Dorn, Gates McFadden, Marina Sirtis, Brent Spiner, Wil Wheaton
Season 4: Jonathan Frakes, Elizabeth Dennehy, LeVar Burton, Michael Dorn, Gates McFadden, Marina Sirtis, Brent Spiner, Wil Wheaton [1]
Season 5: Jonathan Frakes, Elizabeth Dennehy, LeVar Burton, Michael Dorn, Marina Sirtis, Brent Spiner, Colm Meany [2]
Season 6: Jonathan Frakes, Elizabeth Dennehy, LeVar Burton, Michael Dorn, Marina Sirtis, Brent Spiner, Colm Meany, Alexander Siddig, Nana Visitor [3]
Season 7: Elizabeth Dennehy, Avery Brooks, LeVar Burton, Michael Dorn, Marina Sirtis, Brent Spiner, Colm Meany, Alexander Siddig, Nana Visitor [4]
Season 8: Avery Brooks, Michael Dorn, Brent Spiner, Colm Meany, Alexander Siddig, Nana Visitor, Roxann Dawson, Terry Farrell [5]
Season 9: Avery Brooks, Michael Dorn, Brent Spiner, Colm Meany, Alexander Siddig, Nana Visitor, Roxann Dawson, Terry Farrell [6]
Season 10: Avery Brooks, Michael Dorn, Brent Spiner, Colm Meany, Alexander Siddig, Nana Visitor, Roxann Dawson, Terry Farrell [7]
Season 11: Avery Brooks, Michael Dorn, Brent Spiner, Colm Meany, Alexander Siddig, Nana Visitor, Roxann Dawson, Nicole de Boer [8]
Season 12: Kate Mulgrew, Brent Spiner, Colm Meany, Alexander Siddig, Nana Visitor, Roxann Dawson, Nicole de Boer, Garrett Wang [9]
Season 13: Kate Mulgrew, Jonathan Frakes, Nana Visitor, Roxann Dawson, Nicole de Boer, Garrett Wang, Robert Duncan McNeill, Tim Russ, Robert Picardo [10]
Season 14: Kate Mulgrew, Jonathan Frakes, Nana Visitor, Roxann Dawson, Nicole de Boer, Garrett Wang, Robert Duncan McNeill, Tim Russ, Robert Picardo [11]
Season 15: Jonathan Frakes, Nana Visitor, Roxann Dawson, Nicole de Boer, Garrett Wang, Robert Duncan McNeill, Tim Russ, Robert Picardo, Jeri Ryan [12]
Season 16: Jonathan Frakes, Nana Visitor, Roxann Dawson, Nicole de Boer, Garrett Wang, Robert Duncan McNeill, Tim Russ, Robert Picardo, Jeri Ryan [13]
Season 17: Jonathan Frakes, Nana Visitor, Roxann Dawson, Nicole de Boer, Garrett Wang, Robert Duncan McNeill, Tim Russ, Robert Picardo, Jeri Ryan [14]
Season 18: Jonathan Frakes, Nana Visitor, Roxann Dawson, Nicole de Boer, Garrett Wang, Robert Duncan McNeill, Tim Russ, Robert Picardo, Jeri Ryan [15]

1680577786447.png

[1] Star Trek: The Next Generation was no stranger to cast changes by the time their fourth season premiered. Denise Crosby was unhappy with the lack of development for her character Tasha Yar, who was killed off, somewhat unceremoniously, to accommodate her wish to leave. Gates McFadden was fired between the first and second seasons due to disputes with the then-head writer, only to be brought back at the behest of Patrick Stewart for the third season. The reunion would be short-lived, as Stewart himself would become embroiled in contract disputes towards the end of the production season. This led to the famous cliffhanger "The Best of Both Worlds" where Captain Jean-Luc Picard was assimilated by the Borg. Stewart agreed to return for a guest appearance to resolve the cliffhanger at the start of the fourth season, where Picard regains his humanity in the climax only to destroy the Borg spacecraft posed to take over the Federation, and himself along with them. Jonathan Frakes was promoted to top billing behind-the-scenes and William Riker was promoted to Captain on-screen. After a guest appearance in the finale of season 3, Elizabeth Dennehy joined the main cast as the new first officer, Shelby. Riker and Shelby would have a more fraught relationship, with the former still determined to be the man of action whilst the by-the-book and ambitious latter would but heads over allowing the captain to lead away teams.

[2] The fifth season saw McFadden depart the main cast again, along with Wil Wheaton who played her on-screen son Wesley Crusher. The on-screen explanation was that Dr. Crusher had returned to Starfleet Medical, and Wesley had enrolled at Starfleet Academy. Both of them would return for a guest appearance in "The First Duty" during the season, featuring the odd situation of two former main cast members acting as guests along with a future main cast member. At the same time, Colm Meany, who had played the originally nameless Conn officer in the pilot which grew into being Miles O'Brien following recurring appearances over the next three seasons, was promoted to series regular. Other recurring characters introduced this season included the Enterprise's new medical officer, Dr. Julian Bashir (Alexander Siddig, then credited as Siddig El Fadil), and Ro Laren (Nana Visitor, who stepped into the role after the original actor, Michelle Forbes, fell ill days before filming was due to begin). The latter also introduced the new alien race Bajorans, who would go on to play a major part in subsequent seasons alongside their adversaries, the Cardassians, who had first appeared in season four.

[3] Siddig and Visitor were both promoted to main cast the following season, both had been created with the understanding that they might be promoted to series regulars. Behind-the-scenes, Paramount were growing concerned with the increasing salaries of the original main cast members. That casting changes were now part-and-parcel and new characters successfully introduced, a solution was in front of them. The first original cast member to depart under such circumstances was, surprisingly, top-billed Frakes. It was recognised as a gamble, so Frakes was offered a regular position as director to keep him on the studio lot. They would also not commit to killing off the character fully so two-thirds of the way through the sixth season the Enterprise would encounter a duplicate of Riker left behind on a planet years ago. The end saw Captain William Riker killed whilst Lieutenant Thomas Riker, as the latter had taken to naming himself, lived and departed the Enterprise to a new assignment. Frakes was credited for the rest of the season, and paid accordingly, leading many fans to speculate he would be back in charge before the end of the season. When that did not materialise, and instead the sixth season ended on a cliffhanger of the Enterprise engineering section being destroyed by new adversaries the Dominion whilst the saucer section crash landed on a planet, the fans proceeded to turn on Shelby.

[4] Dennehy was promoted to first-billed for the seventh season. Avery Brooks, who had appeared as Starfleet engineering Commander Benjamin Sisko in a guest role during season six, was invited back to become the new on-screen First Officer. Brooks agreed when he was also told he'd receive second billing, the producers wishing to consider the Captain then First Officer on-screen titles. Everyone else was listed by their tenure and then alphabetically. Dennehy and Sisko would provide a more harmonious relationship than Riker and Shelby, Sisko being assigned as the designer of the USS Valiant, renamed Enterprise (NCC-1701-E), a smaller, more armed craft equipped with a cloak originally intended to battle the Borg. They were also the first woman and person-of-colour to portray the Captain and First Officer in main roles on a Star Trek series. Unfortunately, the somewhat uncertain way in which Shelby was introduced as Captain, as well as the loss of the Enterprise (NCC-1701-D) turned many fans against Star Trek's first female Captain. Dennehy asked to be released from her contract following a poisonous letter-writing campaign, that only got worse after Patrick Stewart (along with Gates McFadden and Wil Wheaton) guest starred in the episode "Parallels" that saw the Enterprise encounter a plethora of alternate timelines. Under such circumstances, it was decided that it would be wrong to kill off Shelby, so the character became the first Enterprise captain in the series to leave of their own volition to a new assignment. Dennehy appeared several times in season 8 as the Captain of the USS Challenger.

[5] Benjamin Sisko became Captain of the Intrepid-class Enterprise, and for the first time since Will Riker, an existing crew member became First Officer. Michael Dorn became the second-billed actor once his character Worf became First Officer, accompanied by a change from operations gold to command red uniforms. LeVar Burton (Geordi La Forge) and Marina Sirtis (Deanna Troi) both left the series at the end of the seventh season. The former was offered a similar deal to Frakes, the was not and the studio just refused to pay what she wanted. In their place were two new female characters (an intentional reaction to the largely misogynistic anti-Shelby campaign): Roxann Dawson played Briana Torres and Terry Farrell as Jadzia Dax. Both characters were introduced on-screen as former colleagues of Sisko: Torres, a human, as his deputy engineer in the shipyards, and Dax, a member of the symbiotic Trill species, the latest host for his former mentor. The season also saw Denise Crosby return as another alternate incarnation of Tasha Yar, this time for a brief sojourn to the Mirror Universe, not seen since The Original Series. More returning guest stars were Robert Duncan McNeill and Tim Russ as Nicholas Locarno and Tuvok, respectively. McNeill had first appeared in season five as the ostensible antagonist in "The First Duty". Russ in the sixth season episode "Tapestry" as an unnamed Vulcan officer in an alternate timeline. Like Meany before him, Russ's character was given a name this time around as a former Starfleet officer working with Locarno and the rebellious Maquis.

[6] The Maquis had been seeded since the sixth season, were named in the seventh, and been a recurring element since. The ninth season saw their involvement increase in a major way. Jonathan Frakes returned for the first time since the sixth season as Thomas Riker, who proceeded to hijack the Enterprise tactical section (containing the cloaking device) leaving the main sections stranded in Cardassian space. The episode "Prodigal Son" ended with Riker captured by the Cardassians after offering himself in exchange for the safety of the Enterprise. The ninth season also introduced Kate Mulgrew as Captain Janeway, Captain of the USS Defiant with responsibility for pursuing the Maquis. It is revealed in her introductory episode "Deep Cover" that her agent within the Maquis was recurring character Tuvok, though this was still secret from all the other characters including the Maquis. This created a continuity error since Tuvok was seen helping Thomas Riker earlier in the season but had apparently been operating on Janeway's orders the entire time.

[7] Frakes would return for several episodes across season 10 and 11, escaping Cardassian imprisonment and becoming a recurring adversary for both Sisko and, less mutually respectful, Janeway. Tuvok would appear as the first officer on-board his captured Klingon bird-of-prey the Valjean. Elsewhere in the season, "You Are Cordially Invited" would see many former cast members of The Next Generation appear together on-screen for the wedding of Worf and Dax. La Forge, both Crushers, Troi and Shelby would all appear together in the episode. La Forge in particular would have a large role undergoing Worf's Klingon bridegroom ceremonies alongside complaining Bashir and O'Brien, a respectful Sisko, and a nonchalant Data. Another guest appearance, albeit one from a future main cast member, was Robert Picardo's introduction as the Emergency Medical Hologram. Originally just called the Doctor but changed after Fox launched their adaptation of the British series Doctor Who. Picardo would be invited back for another guest appearance the following season. Most notably, the tenth season featured the first death of a main cast member since season six. Jadzia Dax would be killed by an agent of the Dominion in the tenth season finale "Casus Belli". Farrell had grown tired of the long hours required from television production, and despite willingness to become a recurring character was killed to up the stakes ahead of the planned war storyline of season 11.

[8] That Farrell was recast the next season with Nicole de Boer as the new host of the Dax symbiote incensed many fans. There was concern of another poisonous campaign as with Shelby several years earlier, but this did not come to pass. Most of the fans who might have complained were more concerned with an ongoing war arc in a Star Trek series and controversial episodes like "Far Beyond the Stars". Mulgrew and Russ would make an additional guest appearance each as Janeway and Tuvok during this season. Two more shocking developments were the death of Worf in the lead up to the multi-part season finale, the Klingon dying in battle with the Dominion ramming his runabout into their flagship. And the more quiet departure of Sisko, who moved to Bajor with his new bride, already pregnant, and his teenage son Jake (Cirroc Lofton). Both men had different reasons for leaving, Dorn found himself in the same situation as Sirtis had four years earlier. His departure left Brent Spiner the sole remaining cast member from the first season. Brooks, on the other hand, simply felt his character arc had run its course and worked with the writers to create a satisfying conclusion.

[9] After three years of well-received guest appearances, Kate Mulgrew became the star of Star Trek: The Next Generation and her character, Kathryn Janeway, the second female captain of the USS Enterprise. Garrett Wang also joined the cast as naive Ensign Harry Kim, brought on by Janeway after serving under her on the Defiant during an Academy assignment. Season twelve was more notable for who was on the way out than on the way in. On-screen, after chafing under the new commander, Briana Torres defected to the Maquis near the end of the season. This came after several episodes of speculation that it would be Ro Laren, long sympathetic to the Maquis, who would defect. Behind-the-scenes, both Brent Spiner and Colm Meany would leave the series at the end of the season. Both had appeared as early as the pilot, and Spiner in particular meant there was no no original main cast members from The Next Generation left as they moved into season 13. Data, finally have reached the position of First Officer, left Starfleet to pursue the meaning of life, whilst O'Brien left to work with Sisko on the new shipyards near Bajor. Already having lasted ten seasons longer than its predecessor and longer than most straight drama series never mind science fiction there was finally some real talk of ending the show. However, it had been a cornerstone of the UPN network since it debuted in 1995, having moved their from first-run-syndication. It was still one of the better performing programs on the network alongside the newly debuted WWF SmackDown!

[10] Instead, it was decided to retool the program for its thirteenth season. Jonathan Frakes had made a single guest appearance during the twelfth season, and was promoted back to main cast for the thirteenth. Joining him were other recurring guest stars Robert Duncan McNeill, Robert Picardo and Tim Russ as Locarno, the EMH, and Tuvok. The retooling, planned since before the twelfth season and part of the reason behind Spiner and Meany being encouraged to move on, saw the Enterprise catapulted across the galaxy before the Bajoran wormhole closed forever. Alongside them was a the Vajean. Their arrival in the Gamma quadrant saw both ships meet with major damage and death, including Dr. Bashir, with Alexander Siddig accepting a guest appearance after season twelve to kill off his character. The feature-length season opener ended with the Maquis crew (Riker, Locarno, Tuvok, and Torres) accepting the parole of Captain Janeway (Riker's former nemesis) to serve on the Enterprise as they made their way across the galaxy. Riker became first officer of the Enterprise, a position Thomas Riker had never served in, and was forced to confront that his right-hand man, Tuvok, had been a Starfleet plant. Locarno took up position at conn, Tuvok at security, and Torres took her old position as Chief Engineer. The EMH took over as ship's CMO from Bashir, and most fans rejoiced.

[11] The Next Generation had for years done a mix of standalone episodes alongside two part stories and a handful that combined together formed longer story arcs. Said story arcs included the Cardassian evacuation of Bajor, the Klingon/Federation split, the war with the Dominion, and the escape from Dominion space. Season fourteen differed in most of the episodes formed part of an ongoing story arc. Nicknamed "Year of Hell", the season had the Enterprise having finally escaped Dominion space falling afoul of the history altering Kremin. The Enterprise underwent continual damage throughout the season, and recurring characters were killed off. The Kremin were eventually defeated when Captain Janeway activated a modified photon torpedo to wipe them from history at the cost of her life. The final scene saw the beleaguered Maquis and Starfleet crews together on the bridge, with the former finally having adopted Starfleet uniforms as the final request of their late Captain. The season ended with Maquis Thomas Riker, whose rank at the time of his defection was only Lieutenant Commander, in command of the Enterprise.

[12] The main cast would remain largely stable for the remaining years of the programme, which some have blamed for a staleness of those final seasons. First Officer under Thomas Riker was Ro Laren, both she and her actor Nana Visitor by then being the longest tenured member of the crew on- and behind-the-scenes. This created some chafing from some Starfleet members of the crew given her prior history and sympathy for the Maquis. The season also saw the introduction of the final main cast member, Jeri Ryan as the former Borg Seven of Nine. The form-fitting costume they had Ryan squeezed into has long been assumed for keeping the series alive for another few reasons. The season also saw Wil Wheaton reprise his role as Wesley Crusher for the first time in five years, being the first one to contact the Enterprise and spread word of their survival. After the introduction of Seven, the writers tried to keep the story arcs ongoing with the Temporal Cold War arc. A poorly received storyline not originally conceived for Star Trek and seen as being too similar in some respects to the Krenim arc from the prior season. The revelation of an alternate future Thomas Riker being behind the Cold War left more fans confused, and the arc was quietly dropped without any real resolution.

[13] Season sixteen saw the writers reduce the recurring elements at the producers behest. The result was the most standalone episodic season since the early 1990s. Another request at the behest of the producers was to reintroduce the Borg as the main adversary. Having managed to kill off Captain Picard, the Borg appeared frequently in the fourth season with appearances being reduced in each subsequent season until the Borg only appeared every two or three years. You weren't Captain of the Enterprise in the 24th Century without facing the Borg at least once. The Borg gave way to the Cardassians who gave way to a brief villainous run for the Klingons (timed to coincide with the launch of UPN) who in turn gave turn to the Dominion then to the Krenim for a season then the Temporal Cold War. The producers wanted the Borg back in a big way, which made some semblance of sense since it was now confirmed that after several roundabout turns the Enterprise was now in their native Delta Quadrant.

[14] The seventeenth season saw many former cast members return for guest appearances. Denise Crosby and Michael Dorn appeared as the Mirror Universe counterparts of Tasha Yar and Worf, respectively, for a two-part episode set entirely in the evil dimension. LeVar Burton appeared as Captain La Forge in the alternate future portrayed in "Timeless"; Burton having directed the episode and stepped in as a cameo. Marina Sirtis, Colm Meany and Avery Brooks all appeared in episodes focusing on Starfleet's efforts to maintain communication and return the Enterprise home.

[15] By 2004, the television landscape, and especially the science fiction television landscape, was a far different beast from when Star Trek: The Next Generation had debuted. It was even far different from how it was at the turn of the century. Doctor Who had gone back home to the BBC after five seasons on Fox before a mostly nonplussed US audience. The X-Files ended in 2003 after it's eleventh and final season with Hart Bochner and Annabeth Gish proved conclusively that they could not "do a Next Generation". Stargate SG-1 had been unceremoniously cancelled in 2002 after it's fifth season. Meanwhile, both the remake of Battlestar Galactica (helmed by former Next Generation alumnus Ronald D. Moore, and long suspected reason for the reintroduction of the Borg to counter the appeal of the Cylons) and Joss Whedon's Firefly were doing far better ratings than Star Trek. The decision was made that The Next Generation's eighteenth season (a massive achievement) would be its last. As many former cast members as possible were sought for guest roles in the massive finale. The finale saw the final confrontation with Borg, where Thomas Riker would echo the actions of Captain Picard and sacrifice himself to destroy Unimatrix Zero. The producers actually sought Patrick Stewart to appear in flashbacks as Picard, much as Kate Mulgrew would, but were unable to arrange scheduling around the filming of X-Men III. After his death Ro Laren became the final on-screen Captain of the Enterprise, with Tuvok becoming first officer. They would lead the ship back to the Alpha Quadrant where it would be reunited with La Forge, the Crushers, Troi, Data, Shelby, O'Brien, and Sisko. The final scene saw the current and former main cast gather on the bridge, where a toast was raised to Enterprise's homecoming and "absent friends." The final shot saw the USS Challenger (Shelby) and USS Excelsior (La Forge), both Galaxy-class ships, escort the Intrepid-class Enterprise back to Earth. Over this, the famous opening monologue of the series (and its predecessor) was repeated, editing together the narration of the six actors to have played Captain of the Enterprise as a main cast member: Patrick Stewart, Jonathan Frakes, Elizabeth Dennehy, Avery Brooks, Kate Mulgrew and Nana Visitor.
 
SG-1 cut down in its prime, Firefly probably outliving its welcome... I have thoughts.
I never write utopias.

And on Firefly, without it's cancelation it's going to go down in estimation very quickly. Far quicker than the years it took for BSG to be seen with no clothes. What we know of some of the plans had Firefly survived do make this almost an inevitability.
Mostly "Well done!"
Thankee!

Some minor points that never made it into the write-up:
  • Following Picard's death, they never drop the idea that Wesley might be his biological son. Though it is never confirmed.
  • Since the series is on for so long, wanted all of the Original Series cast members to appear at least once. Nimoy, Doohan, Takei and Whitney as they did on TNG and VOY OTL. Shatner as Mirror Kirk in one of the final seasons, but could not think of anything for Nichols or Koenig.
  • The second half of season 9 and the first half of season 10 occur during 1996 and as such form the anniversary of TOS debut. It's more like the twentieth season of Doctor Who with almost every episode featuring some callback element to series history.
 
I never write utopias.

And on Firefly, without it's cancelation it's going to go down in estimation very quickly. Far quicker than the years it took for BSG to be seen with no clothes. What we know of some of the plans had Firefly survived do make this almost an inevitability.

Yeah, it definitely died at just the right time in OTL.

Some minor points that never made it into the write-up:
  • Since the series is on for so long, wanted all of the Original Series cast members to appear at least once. Nimoy, Doohan, Takei and Whitney as they did on TNG and VOY OTL. Shatner as Mirror Kirk in one of the final seasons, but could not think of anything for Nichols or Koenig.

Extremely senior admirals or members of the Federation Council, perhaps?
 
Extremely senior admirals or members of the Federation Council, perhaps?
I didn't want everyone to be alive in the 24th Century, from what we see of the only human member of the original crew still alive it's way beyond even the most optimistic human life expectancy. McCoy likely keeps himself alive through a combination of artificial organs and witchcraft purely to spite Spock.

An idea I had for Uhura was for her to be the Captain they're rescuing in "The Sound of Her Voice", which was a bit grim. For Chekov, I thought that "Flashback" might become a two parter which is as close to the desired Excelsior series as was ever possible, with Sulu as Captain and Chekov as First Officer.

Didn't want to get too bogged down in individual episodes however unless it was a guest appearance by a former or future TNG main cast member. Hence why I didn't go into recurring characters like Q, Lwaxana Troi, Keiko O'Brien et al.
 
Starfleet Academy

Captain Jonathan Archer (Scott Backula): Born and raised an explorer, a bit lighthearted, a bit of a renegade; now finding he's 'the man' to the students he has to teach. He has to balance installing a sense of duty and protocol with installing a sense of wonder about what's out there and teaching them when to 'bend' rules. Seen as the 'cool' teacher, he has to learn he's still a teacher and has to be strict, not their friend. Had a battlefield promotion to captain during the Second Battle of Chin'toka and still holds a grudge against Cardassians and Breen.

Travis Mayweather (Mekhi Phifer): A "space boomer", someone who has spent their entire life on spaceships and space stations; already an adept pilot and practical mechanic with experience of alien races, he's got the natural talent & instinct for Starfleet but struggles now to learn all the protocols and rules. The ideal Kirk deaged to 20. A leader of kids and clashing with Archer. Doesn't like to admit that planet life is strange to him; he likes to sneak off to the zero-gravity training rooms to have a "proper" nap, rather than stick to a bed.

T'Pol (Jolene Blalock): Uncomfortable around emotional species, cautious and guarded, and a few years older than most; seen as an austere figure by her classmates; initially a remote figure that hangs out with the Vulcan clique. Secretly, she finds she envies humans and is fascinated with their culture, their food, and even their mating rituals. Starts to hang out with the rest of the cast at first as a covert way of getting up close with Earth culture, gradually coming to like them as people even if she won't admit it. Sensual despite austerity.

Hoshi Sato (Linda Park): Feisty and intelligent, her attitude can test the patience of every teacher and half of her friends. She's grown up learning languages from private tutors and can manipulate her vocal chords to admit a range of alien sounds; training for communications, diplomacy, and translation, she tries to test out a variety of alien languages on her classmates and the San Francisco bars. Unfortunately has 'astrophobia' and can't stand the thought of warp travel in a "tin can".

Charles "Trip" Trucker III (Jensen Ackles): An intelligent engineering student; also a Southerner with an offbeat, often sarcastic sense of humour; he enjoys playing up a 'country' persona to wrongfoot or disarm people. Earned a reputation as a troubleshooter who will take on any challenge. What holds him back is he's had little first-hand experience with alien cultures and is often struggling to learn how to best interact with the Vulcans, Andorans, Betazeds and others in his classes. He and T'Pol traffic in the same sarcastic quips.

Malcolm Reed (Tom Hardy): In an age of enlightenment, Reed is a bit of a throwback; a soldier, all spit and polish and by-the-book; maintains a rigorous daily schedule and studies hard. Despite this obsession with regulation, he's also soft spoken, shy, and awkward around women. Slightly older than others; what he doesn't talk about is that he served for several months as a soldier in the Dominion War, something only Archer knows at the start, and this is his 'GI bill'.

Phlox (Anthony Montgomery): Medical student 'Phloxx-tunnai-oortann' (he goes by 'Phlox' for our benefit) has an oblique sense of humour and no familiarity with Earth culture; finds our social customs and sexual mores fascinating, and is constantly having humorous misunderstandings. His planet has only just joined the Federation; another 'mature student', he's qualified in medicine at home and he's here to learn Starfleet's ways & teach Starfleet his; Phlox has brought bizarre technology and practices, and every practical exercise is an adventure.

--

Starfleet Academy was initially a show set in the titular school and worked as a sci-fi teen drama, intending to bring a younger audience back to the franchise. Declining ratings over the first year led to a major revamp in season 2: the cast were now the crew of the USS Intrepid, a decommissioned Galaxy-class now being used as a training vessel, which allowed them to be drawn into more traditional Trek stories while keeping the premise of teens-in-training going. This would slow the decline but not enough to save the show
 
Had a battlefield promotion to captain during the Second Battle of Chin'toka and still holds a grudge against Cardassians and Breen.
This was my first twig that this ain't no prequel show.
Travis Mayweather (Mekhi Phifer)
At first thought Phifer was too old for the role then found out to my shock that he's three years younger than Tony Monty (Anthony Montgomery).
Secretly, she finds she envies humans and is fascinated with their culture, their food, and even their mating rituals.
This is mid-00s UPN after all.
Malcolm Reed (Tom Hardy)
Despite there being somany examples of this nowadays still feel this one would stand out in an ATL. Hardy could play a main role in the few seasons this is on the hair but people would no more raise an eyebrow at him in The Dark Knight Rises than they did Ronan Dex as Aquaman in Batman v Super. Notable, but not impossible.
 
This is only like a half-baked thought, but I realised recently that you can butterfly away a lot of modern female artists in pop and pop punk music, if you only have Paramore never form up. There are just so many of them who claim Paramore as an influence, and like, it makes sense, right? Having a female lead singer "as a thing" was pretty notable at the time, but eventually made it "normal" and helped inspire a generation of new artists and groups who directly cite them as an influence (chloe moriondo, PVRIS, WILLOW, Tessa Violet, CHVRCHES, Meet Me @ the Altar; basically every female-led pop-punk adjacent group/artist) in what was otherwise a very male-dominated scene, and that's not even getting to the uncited influence on music seen in like Olivia Rodrigo and Billie Eilish, etc, who clearly have a lot of stylistic influences from Paramore, even if not acknowledged by the artists themselves (good 4 u is literally just a modern day Misery Business!). There's a lot of PoDs to make Paramore never happen, too, like Hayley Williams' family not moving to Tennessee.
 
Back
Top