My Hero, Spiro
or,
Fear, Loathing, and Old Bay
or,
ATLF: Fear, Loathing, and Gumbo on the Campaign Trail '72, but only the parts I actually remembered reading
(This entry corresponds to HoS List Challenges #9 ["The Return"] and #24 ["ATLFs"]).
1969-1973: Richard M. Nixon (Republican)
1973-1973: Spiro Agnew (Republican, acting)
'72 Richard M. Nixon (R), John J. McKeithen (Democratic), and George C. Wallace (AIP) advance to contingent election over George McGovern (Peace)
'72 Spiro Agnew (R) def. Birch Bayh (Democratic) in contingent Vice Presidential election
1973-1973: Spiro Agnew (Republican)
'73 John J. McKeithen (Democratic, deceased) wins contingent election; as McKeithen is ineligible, Agnew succeeds to Presidency
1973-1976: James Gavin (no party affiliation)
'73 Agnew resigns facing impeachment
'73 William Scranton (R) appointed Vice President
1976-1977: William Scranton (Republican)
'76 Gavin assassinated by Fuerzas Armadas de Liberación Nacional Puertorriqueña
1977-1981: Spiro Agnew ("Agnew" Republican)
'76 (with John B. Connally) def. Ted Kennedy (Democratic), William Scranton ("Main Street" Republican)
'78 Connally resigns
'78 Phyllis Schlafly (Republican) appointed Vice President
1981-1981: Richard M. Nixon (Republican/Alliance)
'80 (with Reubin Askew) def. Spiro Agnew (Republican)
1981-1985: Reubin Askew (Democratic/Alliance, then Moderate)
'81 Nixon dies of phlebitis
'81 Margaret Heckler (Republican/AHP) appointed Vice President
1985-1988: Phyllis Schlafly (Republican)
'84 (with John Porter East) def. Reubin Askew (Moderate)
We all know the story. Louisiana Governor John J. McKeithen emerges out of nowhere in 1972 to take the Presidential nomination, then manages - just barely - to deadlock the Presidential race against Nixon. As George Wallace holds the Presidency hostage for segregation and his own ambitions, the Senate selects Agnew for the Vice Presidency (and thus the Acting Presidency) by a single vote - his own. Agnew's disastrous Acting Presidency and an assassination attempt on former President Nixon lead the man to make a deal with McKeithen to resolve the situation, just in time for McKeithen to die in a plane crash of all the things. But as Agnew's Presidency continues to circle the drain, his past corruption back in Maryland catches up to him, and his decision to pardon himself only exacerbates the crisis. Impeachment and replacement with James M. Gavin, an almost universally respected general without partisan affiliation, solves the problem - particularly after Agnew decides to jump before he's pushed, trusting in the American people to understand him as a victim and act accordingly.
Gavin's Presidency got off to a bad start. As Agnew made his way to the redoubts of the right-wing press and nascent talk radio, Gavin worked feverishly to bring an end to the Vietnam War just as other crises were building. The economic situation had already been undermined by Nixon's inflationary policies and the previous year's political uncertainty; as the Middle East spiraled into war, rising oil prices only exacerbated the issue, plunging the United States into a level of economic sickness not seen since the Thirties. Meanwhile, despite the better efforts of Secretary of State Nixon, China repudiated the thaw in relations and plunged into renewed terror, while Brezhnev's sudden death led to bloody power struggles in the Soviet Union. An organized and militant right wing, led on by a network of policy institutes and agitprop spigots, organized, winning control of the House in the 'Bloodbath of '74' as safe Democratic seats across the South and Midwest fell to right-wing cadres. Gavin himself would be dead just months before his term was up, with the FALN linking up with the remnants of the Weather Underground (and, allegedly, with Cuban intelligence) to assassinate him with a car bomb. With Ted Kennedy's campaign bogged down in the Senator's own baggage and conflicts with his own party, the way was clear for the resistible return of Spiro Agnew.
The next four years were deeply controversial, to say the least. The FBI turned loose to go after Agnew's political enemies but unwilling to prosecute the Klansmen who shot Judge John Minor Wisdom and murdered an estimated sixty other people. Doubling the number of Americans in prison amidst a nationwide War on Crime, with many political prisoners disappearing forever, never to be found. Pervasive censorship of the press to cover up abuses across the system, as well as pervasive corruption. Bloody conflicts in Angola, Korea, and Yemen. For around a quarter to a third of Americans, this was the first truly patriotic and constitutional government in a generation, if not more. For a narrow majority, it was somewhere between regrettably and embarrassingly excessive and outright fascism. The mainstream of the Democratic Party and the "Main Street" faction of the Republicans combined, first to take back control of Congress, then to take back the Presidency - and, with the tailwinds of a shitty economy, they succeeded. But their standard-bearer had feet of clay - more importantly, he had veins of clay, coupled with the long-term effects of the assassination attempt eight years prior.
Reubin Askew was, in some respects, a better figure for the job than Nixon had been. An outsider, unconnected to the system and with hands unbloodied by it. A figure of widely-respected probity and humility. A Southern Catholic with civil-rights credentials. But he was also a figure of domestic politics in an era defined by foreign policy - the unwinding of America's foreign wars, the crushing of reform in the Soviet Union, and the aftershocks of the invasion of Hong Kong. When former Vice President Schlafly became the first female President, it was hardly a surprise. And when her belief that arms control agreements were a bad joke and the communist system would collapse given one good kick were combined into policy, the results
1988-1991: various claimants inc. Charles Wilson (Moderate), Donald Rumsfeld (Republican), and James "Bo" Gritz (military)
'88 Schlafly and East killed in atomic bombing of Washington, D.C.
'88 Secretary of State Rumsfeld forms American Continuity Government in London, UK
'88 Gritz declares self "Acting Commander-in-Chief", begins recruiting military and police units from Carson City, NV
'89 Surviving members of House of Representatives elect Wilson Speaker and therefore President in Santa Fe, NM
1991-2001: Donald Rumsfeld (National Recovery)
'91 Wilson, Gritz, and several regional warlords sign Asilomar Declaration, forming consensus government led by Rumsfeld
'92 (with Charlie Wilson) effectively unopposed
'93 Wilson resigns due to health issues
'93 John Otho Marsh II appointed Vice President
'96 (with John Otho Marsh II) def. Bo Gritz (Federalist), Angela Davis (Socialist Unity)
2001-2003: John Otho Marsh II (National Recovery)
'00 (with Evan Bayh) def. Steve Largent (Christian), Bo Gritz (Federalist), Bill Browder (Socialist Unity)
2003-2009: Evan Bayh (National Recovery)
'03 Marsh assassinated by United Florida Reconquista Command
'04 (with Andrew Schlafly) def. Helen Hage (Federalist), James Hoffa (Labor), Larry Sanders (Ecological)
2009-2009: James "Bo" Gritz (Independence!)
'08 (with Pat Choate) def. Evan Bayh (National Recovery), Andrew Schlafly (Conservative)
2009-2013: Pat Choate (Independence!)
'09 Gritz dies by suicide
'09 John McAfee appointed Vice President
'11 McAfee impeached
'11 James N. Rowe appointed Vice President
2013-2016: Gary Condit (National Recovery)
'12 (with R. Ted Cruz) def. Pat Choate (Independence!), John McAfee (Unbowed)
2016-2019: Rafael Cruz Jr. (National Recovery)
'16 Condit resigns due to extramarital affair
'16 (with John Kitzhaber) def. Ammon Bundy (Unbowed), Peter Navarro (Independence!)
2019-: John Kitzhaber (National Recovery)
'19 Cruz impeached for ineligibility
'20 (with Valerie Davidson) effectively unopposed
Donald Rumsfeld was saved by what had been, up until the moment the balloon went up, the bane of his existence. Western Europe had been badly affected by the twitches and grunts of the American elephant - bad diplomacy choking off its oil, bad politics spraying instability throughout the world, not to mention protectionism hurting industrial employment throughout the continent. Grim Grom may have seen dealing with Europe as a fool's errand under normal circumstances, but he spotted the opportunity to drive a wedge right down the Atlantic. Among other things, that meant that when Secretary of State Donald Rumsfeld met with Prime Minister Benn in London to try to dictate terms on intelligence-sharing and American use of British bases, he was a safe distance away from the apocalypse.
Crisis created its own opportunities, and for none more than Donald Rumsfeld. Determining himself to be the highest-ranking surviving member of the line of Presidential succession, he proceeded to form a continuity government in exile. Though others made their own claims, Rumsfeld could do something they couldn't - he could go, hat in hand, to the strongest powers left behind, and promise them reconstruction on favorable terms if they backed him over Wilson. Armed with the support of Owen, Mitterrand, and Ozawa, he returned to American shores in 1990, then used his foreign backing to negotiate with the others from a position of strength. Asilomar formalized the status quo - the future of America would be technocratic, skeptical of civil liberties, and corporate.
The first signs of trouble came from Bo Gritz. Hero of the wars in Vietnam and Angola, Gritz had been America's most successful warlord, bringing together surviving military and police units from the Oregon high desert to the Georgia Piedmont to share resources, training, and intelligence. His government fought organized and disorganized crime across the nation, and helped make long-range transportation possible again - but the average Gritz supporter thought Spiro Agnew hadn't gone far enough, and his government's human rights record combined personalist rule by a military officer with an antisemitic streak with the decentralized terror and cruelty of a warlord state without central control. Given amnesty under the terms of Asilomar, Gritz saw Rumsfeldia as a surrender to the same socialists and liberals that had gotten America into the mess in the first place, and formed the Federalist Party as a backstop to protect law-abiding Christian communities from the long arm of the One World Government.
As time went on, Gritz' right-wing cry of despair was joined by one from the left. Rumsfeld's government - and those of his successors - saw labor rights deteriorate massively, as the pressures of a struggling economy harmonized with the demands of international companies like British Petroleum and Aso Mining. It also saw a widespread reversion to extraction and "dirty" manufacturing, with devastating ecological consequences. Rumsfeld dropped Wilson to pander to the right, gave Evan Bayh high office to pander to the left, and oversaw Andrew Schlafly's installation as Vice President to pander to the right again - but none of it was able to stop the shaky left-right coalition that was the Independence! Party.
What was able to stop it was the lack of a way out. Two decades of Rumsfeldism and reconstruction had brought America back to a limited sort of prosperity, but that prosperity was dependent on a steady stream of overseas investment. With a third of its landmass still too irradiated for settlement and healthcare and security constant drains on the budget, any capital strikes that interrupted that flow would be disastrous. The situation took a heavy toll on Gritz as a person, with devastating results; the mild-mannered economist Choate was able to convince the World Bank to tolerate restructuring and renegotiation, but he was himself undermined by his own party. Most Independence! voters didn't want to compromise with the World Bank - they wanted to vaporize it.
Since Rumsfeld's retirement, the National Recovery machine has more or less chugged along like it did under his rule. Condit, the Governor of California chosen to appeal to both middle-class cosmopolitan internationalists and soft environmentalists, submitted to a shotgun wedding with evangelical legal scholar Rafael Cruz Jr., then blew his own Presidency up by having an affair with a college student; Cruz, meanwhile, was dogged by constitutional questions over his Canadian birth and general questions about his closeness with people in Gritz's circles, some of whom were now providing constitutional justifications for protracted people's war against the United States government. As the militia crisis reached its third decade, Vice President Kitzhaber wrote the country a prescription - military suppression backed up by strongman rule legitimated by universal provision of austere, limited public goods...