• Hi Guest!

    The costs of running this forum are covered by Sea Lion Press. If you'd like to help support the company and the forum, visit patreon.com/sealionpress

Night Mares (fictional TV show)

varyar

giver of existential dread
Patreon supporter
Published by SLP
Location
Western New York
Still working out the details and fine print on this one, but comments/questions/whatnot would be appreciated.

***

It's all because of cosplay.

I should have started with Night Mares on the ground floor. The premise - occult investigators in the Old West - is right up my alley, and Molly Quinn was one of my favorite cast members on Castle, so I would have been an easy sell. But for some reason, the show wasn't on my radar until the second season. And we're back to cosplay. One day I was browsing the forums at alternatehistory.com and I happened to wrong-click my way into the "Nice cosplay pictures thread" - there, in between an Emma Frost and the Halo guy, whatever his name is, were a pair of women in old west garb, one a gunslinger with a couple undone buttons on her blouse and the other a mousy-frontier-girl with round spectacles. Apparently, these were the Brophy Sisters. A couple Google searches later and I knew what I wanted to watch while waiting for delivery that night.

Night Mares aired on AMC between 2017 and 2021 with a total of 36 episodes. The titular Night Mares were a secret sisterhood of occult investigators, in this case two Irish-American sisters living in San Francisco in the early 1870s. They delved into paranormal mysteries alongside their friends and allies, often butting heads with the sinister high-society forces of the Sphinx Club. The show drew inspiration from sources such as Stephen King, Manly Wade Wellman and shows like Supernatural and The Adventures of Brisco County Jr. (another Weird Western program, but much, much lighter in tone than Night Mares). The sisters in question, Anne and Maggie Brophy, were played by British actress Emily Beecham in her first major American television role and Molly C. Quinn (fresh off her breakout role on Castle). The rest of the main cast consisted of Lewis Tan as the gunslinger Tang Zidaan, Tania Raymonde as Sister Isabel Ramirez of the fictional Order of St. Victoria, Leighton Meester as Hannah Visser, wealthy socialite and hapless member of the Sphinx Club, Demore Barnes as King Brady, a mostly-friendly rival in the occult troubleshooting business, and Nick Frost as the prospector, brawler and drunkard "Savage" Sam Henderson. They were joined by recurring guest stars Orla Brady (Caoimhe McLarney, Anne's mentor), Morena Baccarin, Leven Rambin and Renee Olstead as Caterina Zorzi, the owner of the bar Zorzi, and her 'girls' Jenny and Violet, Terry O'Quinn and Rachel Nichols as father and daughter Thaddeus and Gloria Clarke, the true rulers of the Sphinx Club, and JuJu Chan, Francois Chau, and James Hong as Taam Jimsan, Zungsam and Wahbo, the sister, father and great-uncle of Tang Zidaan.

While not quite rising to the level of prestige television, Night Mares was one of the better sci-fi/horror shows of the late 2010s, elevated by a great cast and generally smart scripts. It had a modest but devoted fanbase and, mercifully, ended in its own time instead of being prematurely cancelled or, perhaps even worse, staggering a few seasons past its sell-by date. Fans are divided on the overall plot about the Sphinx Club's obsessive hunt for Atlantean relics (hinted at once or twice in season 1 and becoming more and more prominent in the second and third seasons). Speaking only for myself, I thought it was an interesting and (for the most part) well-written storyline, even if one does wonder what Atlantis was doing in California of all places.

Season one introduced the characters, both good and evil, and set them off on their arcs while also laying down the rules of the setting (which the show would do a very good job of adhering to over its run - the showrunners clearly learned from the mistakes of earlier programs we won't mention and had both a plan and a setting bible before the first episode was filmed). The stakes were relatively low-key and most of the plots were solved by the end of a given episode, but as the season went on, we learned more and more about the rot beneath the charming facade of the Sphinx Club until the finale both introduced Max Martini as Tim Poole, cold-blooded killer and the Club's enforcer, and unveiled the previously charming Clarkes as murderous devil-worshipers.

In season two, we were introduced to the Atlantis metaplot that would dominate the show going forward. Night Mares version of Atlantis was rooted into Plato's allegory, but only loosely in that the show's Atlantis was an ancient empire that tried to conquer the entire world (long before Greece or even Egypt existed) before being destroyed - by whom, exactly, the show never really answered (giving rise to both fan theories about Atlantis' enemies and speculation the matter would have been addressed in a fourth season that neither AMC nor the showrunners ever planned on). It culminated in the Sphhinx Club locating and plundering an Atlantean tomb, recovering the first of three artifacts the Clarkes needed to achieve their ultimate goal. It also saw significant character growth, especially for Anne and Zidaan, who grew ever closer to each other, and Savage Sam as he left his season one alcoholism and depression well behind.

Everything came to a head in season three, with the Brophies and their allies trying to keep pace with the Sphinx Club even as the Clarkes and Pool steadily picked off their competition as they laid the groundwork for the ritual culmination of their grand plan. There was an increasing air of desperation among the protagonists, not helped by Sister Isabel's crisis of faith and Maggie's existential doubt... before turning the corner in the last five episodes that led up to the tectonic finale and the climactic battle between the Night Mares and the Sphinx Club.

Season One
The first season started with a bang, literally, in the two-part episode "Once Upon a Time in the Weird West" as Anne and Zidaan dynamite a backwoods shack in order to flush out the vampire lurking inside it. We were then introduced to the other main characters and the central location, Zorzi's bar, before the plot whisked along on an adventure involving a haunted mansion outside the city. Part 2 spent most of the time exploring said haunted mansion, allowing the leads to showcase their skills (Anne's intuition, Maggie's book-learning, Zidaan's gunslinging, Sister Isabel's piety, Hannah's social combat skills and King's keen perception); Lera Lynn, the vocalist for the opening credits, made one of a handful of cameos back at Zorzi's with a poignant performance of "Lorena".

episode 3 - "The Sphinx Club", guest starring Ben Browder as Ambrose Bierce. Focuses on Hannah, a wealthy widow and fixture of San Francisco's social scene.

episode 4 - "Haunting at High Noon" ghost town with actual ghosts, "Savage" Sam Henderson's first spotlight episode. The first appearance of the Finnerty Spectacles, a Renaissance device that lets the wearer see into the supernatural world.

episode 5 - "The Mentor" Caoimhe's first appearance as she helps the Brodies out with a particularly nasty serial killer

episode 6 - "Midnight in Massacre Canyon", Sam confronts the ghosts (literally) of his past and begins his recovery arc.

episode 7 - "The Blood Countess" Elizabeth Bathory (Rachel Weisz). Introduces the Convent of St. Eudoxia, where Sister Isabel resides.

episode 8 - "The Wolf of Mariposa County" werewolf that both Anne and King Brady are hunting. B Plot introduces Zidaan's rebellious sister, who has taught herself martial arts and, naturally, gotten into trouble with the local criminals because of her knight errantry.

episode 9 - "Lights on Mount Shasta" ghost lights, Hannah sponsors a study. Meanwhile, Jenny seeks the sisters' help on behalf of her brother Jacob, an independent prospector faced with an unearthly problem.

episode 10 - "Terror on the Train" - https://classicchicagomagazine.com/pullmans-pride-the-pioneer/ Maggie and Sister Isabel spotlight. Guest starring Florence Pugh as an East Coast ingénue who might not be quite as naïve as she appears.

episode 11 - "All Soul's Eve" Maggie joins Sister Isabel in assisting Father Shanahan (Scott Foley) in the exorcism of a haunted house in the rich Pacific Heights neighborhood. Meanwhile, Anne and Zidaan investigate rumors of a subterranean cult and run into a pack of feral troglodytes near Tulare Lake.

episode 12 - "The Talon" (Max Martini) arrives from back east, introduces the Atlantean arc. In the b-plot, a rare comedic turn for the show, Napoleon III and Eugénie, as well as Colonel Zebulon Howell Benton, appear as the former Emperor, seeking to improve his health, has come to California for the climate. Hannah hobnobs with them and accidentally gives offense, ending the imperial interlude in the Bay Area.

Season Two

episode 1 - "The Auction" Atlantean map up for auction, draws attention from the Clarkes as well as a range of other well-heeled types. Ambrose Bierce appears again.

episode 2 - "Goengsi" Chinese vampire fixated on Hannah for some reason. King Brady and Uncle Wahbo help resolve the situation. Meanwhile, Anne and Maggie consult a peculiar old antiquarian (Linda Hunt) about the Atlantean map from the previous episode.

episode 3 - "Devil's Hoof Hill" Katie McGrath in a scenery-chewing turn as villainess Mary Burke. Sister Isabel consults with Father Hugh Taunton, a visiting English priest and supernatural expert (based on real-life Jesuit Father Herbert Thurston).

episode 4 - "Ghost Quelling Society Emergent" Chinese plot pt 1. In this two parter, we are introduced to the Ghost Quelling Society, a group of Taoist occultists not unlike the Brody Sisters and company. They are led by a trio of elders (played by Daniel Wu, Byron Mann and Wai Ching Ho), the former and latter of whom Uncle Wahbo vouches for.

episode 5 - "Ghost Quelling Society Ascendant" Chinese plot pt 2. Shockingly, the elder that Uncle Wahbo doesn't know turns out to be in cahoots with the Sphinx Club, who used the Ghost Quelling Society to take out some of their competition, risk free, and then aim to wipe out the Society - they accomplish the former, but not the later, and Priestess Jyutgwai kills the traitor.

episode 6 - "Dust Devils" - dust devils attack Mary and Zidaan as they are traveling through the mountains. Heavy on atmosphere and romantic tension, a little light on plot.

episode 7 - "Encounter at Hangman Hill" - Dinosaur accidentally brought into the present by the Owl Club experimenting with a relic. B-plot with Hannah and Emperor Norton (Michael Emerson, playing the character as a man with a self-aware humor)

episode 8 - "The Infernal Engine" - spiritualism meets science meets Atlantis, Sister Isabel focus. B plot with Zidaan and King Brady trying to convince a fellow gunslinger and Civil War veteran, Hal Wheeler (Clé Bennett), from going after Poole.

episode 9 - "Anglosophy Club" Prompted by a friend (guest star MIchelle Trachtenberg), Hannah joins a new social club only to discover they're diabolical racists. Her protests lead to her being chosen as the next sacrifice, and ironically it's Poole who saves her when he guns down the leaders of the rival club; Hannah's friend survives the episode, but their friendship decidedly does not.

episode 10 - "The Hidden Circle" Maggie and Ambrose Bierce attending a seance. Bierce, unnerved by what he experiences, decamps for England.

episode 11 - "Old Man Mountain" Atlantean tomb pt 1, Mary Burke returns in alliance with the Sphinx Club

episode 12 - "Old Man Mountain" Atlantean tomb pt 2, Mary, somewhat predictably, gets betrayed by her allies and sacrificed in order to open the tomb

Season Three

episode 1 - "The Evil Eye" the Eye of Harun, an ancient Atlantean artifact, the first of three things the Sphinx Club needs in order to become immortal.

episode 2 - "High Society" Hannah-centric episode with Lena Headey as Isabella Bird (real life traveler and writer; her travels in the American West did indeed take place in 1873)

episode 3 - "Shadow of the Ghost" Chinese episode, B-plot with Isabella Bird and "Savage" Sam Henderson quite friendly with each other. Early fall 1873.

episode 4 - "The Old Mission" Another Sister Isabel and Maggie adventure, a ghostly nun. Ends with the two of them at St. Eudoxia, lighting candles for her.

episode 5 - "Fangs" Bathory returns, targets Maggie who drives her off without any weapons except her faith; bookended by two powerful scenes. The opening, where Bathory stalks and devours Jenny, in which her turn from bored flirtation to desperate terror is a powerful performance that ends with her broken, bloodless body being thrown through the windows of Zorzi's. And the finale, where Maggie lays her bare, empty palm on Bathory's forehead and leaves a jagged scar in the shape of a cross, just before the countess bursts into all-consuming white-hot flame.

episode 6 - "Via Crucis" Maggie begins to question her calling, ends with Caoimhe and Tang Wahbo being abducted. Sister Israbel and Archbishop Joseph Sadoc Alemany y Conill (Tony Amendola)

episode 7 - "The Knife" Caoimhe and Tang Wahbo are killed by the Clarkes and Poole. The second of the three artifacts is recovered, too.

episode 8 - "Memento Mori" - funeral of Tang Wahbo and Caoimhe. Anne and Zidaan's failed attempt at revenge. Ella-Rae Smith as Martha Brady, King's estranged daughter.

episode 9 - "Last Call" - end of the line for Zorzi's. The Sphinx Club locates the third object.

episode 10 - "Tremors" finale pt 1 - tremors

episode 11 - "The Big One" finale pt 2 - the big one, Anne gets her revenge on Gloria and Poole

episode 12 - "Aftershocks" finale pt 3. - aftershocks, the Sphinx Club purged, Anne and Zidaan (and family) bring Uncle Wahbo's body back to China, Maggie takes her vows. King Brady accepts his daughter as an apprentice, and Sam goes back to England - maybe with his eye on a second try with a certain well-mannered traveler....
 
The latest iteration...

It's all because of cosplay.

I should have started with Night Mares from day one. The premise - occult investigators in the Old West - is right up my alley, and Molly Quinn was one of my favorite cast members on Castle, so I would have been an easy sell. But for some reason, the show wasn't on my radar until the second season. And we're back to cosplay. One day I was browsing the forums at alternatehistory.com and I happened to wrong-click my way into the "Nice cosplay pictures thread" - there, in between an Emma Frost and the Halo guy, whatever his name is, were a pair of women in old west garb, one a gunslinger with a couple undone buttons on her blouse and the other a mousy-frontier-girl with round spectacles. Apparently, these were the Brophy Sisters. A couple Google searches later and I knew what I wanted to watch while waiting for delivery that night.

Night Mares aired on AMC between 2017 and 2021 with a total of 36 episodes. The titular Night Mares were a secret sisterhood of occult investigators, in this case two Irish-American sisters living in San Francisco in the early 1870s. They delved into paranormal mysteries alongside their friends and allies, often butting heads with the sinister high-society forces of the Sphinx Club. The show drew inspiration from sources such as Stephen King, Manly Wade Wellman and shows like Supernatural and The Adventures of Brisco County Jr. (another Weird Western program, but much, much lighter in tone than Night Mares). The sisters in question, Anne and Maggie Brophy, were played by British actress Emily Beecham in her first major American television role and Molly C. Quinn (fresh off her breakout role on Castle). The rest of the main cast consisted of Lewis Tan as the gunslinger Tang Zidaan, Tania Raymonde as Sister Isabel Ramirez of the fictional Order of St. Victoria, Leighton Meester as Hannah Visser, wealthy socialite and hapless member of the Sphinx Club, Demore Barnes as King Brady, a mostly-friendly rival in the occult troubleshooting business, and Nick Frost as the prospector, brawler and drunkard "Savage" Sam Henderson. They were joined by recurring guest stars Orla Brady (Caoimhe McLarney, Anne's mentor), Morena Baccarin, Leven Rambin and Renee Olstead as Caterina Zorzi, the owner of the bar Zorzi, and her 'girls' Jenny and Violet, Terry O'Quinn and Rachel Nichols as father and daughter Thaddeus and Gloria Clarke, the true rulers of the Sphinx Club, and JuJu Chan, Francois Chau, and James Hong as Taam Jimsan, Zungsam and Wahbo, the sister, father and great-uncle of Tang Zidaan.

While not quite rising to the level of prestige television, Night Mares was one of the better sci-fi/horror shows of the late 2010s, elevated by a great cast and generally smart scripts. It had a modest but devoted fanbase and, mercifully, ended in its own time instead of being prematurely cancelled or, perhaps even worse, staggering a few seasons past its sell-by date. Fans are divided on the overall plot about the Sphinx Club's obsessive hunt for Atlantean relics (hinted at once or twice in season 1 and becoming more and more prominent in the second and third seasons). Speaking only for myself, I thought it was an interesting and (for the most part) well-written storyline, even if one does wonder what Atlantis was doing in California of all places.

Season one introduced the characters, both good and evil, and set them off on their arcs while also laying down the rules of the setting (which the show would do a very good job of adhering to over its run - the showrunners clearly learned from the mistakes of earlier programs we won't mention and had both a plan and a setting bible before the first episode was filmed). The stakes were relatively low-key and most of the plots were solved by the end of a given episode, but as the season went on, we learned more and more about the rot beneath the charming facade of the Sphinx Club until the finale both introduced Max Martini as Tim Poole, cold-blooded killer and the Club's enforcer, and unveiled the previously charming Clarkes as murderous devil-worshipers.

In season two, we were introduced to the Atlantis metaplot that would dominate the show going forward. Night Mares version of Atlantis was rooted into Plato's allegory, but only loosely in that the show's Atlantis was an ancient empire that tried to conquer the entire world (long before Greece or even Egypt existed) before being destroyed - by whom, exactly, the show never really answered (giving rise to both fan theories about Atlantis' enemies and speculation the matter would have been addressed in a fourth season that neither AMC nor the showrunners ever planned on). It culminated in the Sphinx Club locating and plundering an Atlantean tomb, recovering the first of three artifacts the Clarkes needed to achieve their ultimate goal. It also saw significant character growth, especially for Anne and Zidaan, who grew ever closer to each other, and Savage Sam as he left his season one alcoholism and depression well behind.

Everything came to a head in season three, with the Brophies and their allies trying to keep pace with the Sphinx Club even as the Clarkes and Pool steadily picked off their competition as they laid the groundwork for the ritual culmination of their grand plan. There was an increasing air of desperation among the protagonists, not helped by Sister Isabel's crisis of faith and Maggie's existential doubt... before turning the corner in the last five episodes that led up to the tectonic finale and the climactic battle between the Night Mares and the Sphinx Club.

Season One

The first season started with a bang, literally, in the two-part episode "Once Upon a Time in the Weird West" as Anne and Zidaan dynamite a backwoods shack in order to flush out the vampire lurking inside it. We were then introduced to the other main characters and the central location, Zorzi's bar, before the plot whisked along on an adventure involving a haunted mansion outside the city. Part 2 spent most of the time exploring said haunted mansion, allowing the leads to showcase their skills (Anne's intuition, Maggie's book-learning, Zidaan's gunslinging, Sister Isabel's piety and King's keen perception); Lera Lynn, the vocalist for the opening credits, made one of a handful of cameos back at Zorzi's with a poignant performance of "Lorena".

The third episode, "The Sphinx Club", focused on Hannah, a wealthy widow and fixture of San Francisco's social scene, as she joined the titular club and was presented with the first subtle clues it was more sinister than just an exclusive playhouse for the rich and powerful; also notable for the first of a handful of appearances by Ben Browder as Ambrose Bierce.

The follow up, "Haunting at High Noon," saw our heroes explore a ghost town with actual ghosts. It was "Savage" Sam Henderson's first spotlight episode, as he'd once lived in the town and had to come face to face with the literal ghosts of his past, and also the first appearance of the Finnerty Spectacles, a Renaissance device that let the wearer see into the supernatural world.

"The Mentor'' introduced Caoimhe to the show as she helped the Brophies out in dealing with an especially nasty and not-entirely-human murder. It also widened the show's backstory with the implied existence of many more Night Mares both in the States and the Old Country.

Next up was "Midnight in Massacre Canyon," a straightforward episode culminating in a shoot-em-up finale where Anne and Zidaan gun down a horde of zombies The barely-there B-plot involved Maggie and Sister Isabel tracking down a stolen Catholic relic.

In "The Blood Countess" we were introduced to both Elizabeth Bathory (Katja Herbers) and the Convent of St. Eudoxia, where Sister Isabel resides when not investigating the paranormal; the episode had an atypically high body count, as did the next one, "The Wolf of Mariposa County." This time, the principal source of carnage was a gang of werewolves; the b-plot introduced Zidaan's rebellious younger sister Jimsan, who has taught herself martial arts and, naturally, gotten into trouble with the local criminals because of her knight errantry.

The next episode, "Lights on Mount Shasta," was a lot lighter in tone. Hannah hires both Anne and King Brady to investigate the mysterious lights; meanwhile, Jenny seeks Zidaan and Sister Isabel's help on behalf of her brother Jacob, an independent prospector faced with an unearthly problem. In "Terror on the Train," Maggie and Sister Isabel spend the hour on a ritzy Pullman train from San Francisco to Utah; guest starring Florence Pugh as an East Coast ingénue who might not be quite as naïve as she appears.

In "All Soul's Eve" Maggie joins Sister Isabel in assisting Father Shanahan (Scott Foley) in the exorcism of a haunted house in the rich Pacific Heights neighborhood. Meanwhile, Anne and Zidaan investigate rumors of a subterranean cult and run into a pack of feral troglodytes near Tulare Lake. And the season came to a head in "The Talon" where said Talon (Max Martini's Poole) arrived from back east and introduced the Atlantean plot that dominated the show going forward. In the b-plot, a rare comedic turn for the show, Napoleon III and Eugénie, as well as Colonel Zebulon Howell Benton, appear as the former Emperor, seeking to improve his health, has come to California for the climate. Hannah hobnobs with them and accidentally gives offense, ending the imperial interlude in the Bay Area.

Season Two

episode 1 - "The Auction" Atlantean map up for auction, draws attention from the Clarkes as well as a range of other well-heeled types. Ambrose Bierce appears again.

episode 2 - "Goengsi" Chinese vampire fixated on Hannah for some reason. King Brady and Uncle Wahbo help resolve the situation. Meanwhile, Anne and Maggie consult a peculiar old antiquarian (Linda Hunt) about the Atlantean map from the previous episode.

episode 3 - "Devil's Hoof Hill" Katie McGrath in a scenery-chewing turn as villainess Mary Burke. Sister Isabel consults with Father Hugh Taunton, a visiting English priest and supernatural expert (based on real-life Jesuit Father Herbert Thurston).

episode 4 - "Ghost Quelling Society Emergent" Chinese plot pt 1. In this two parter, we are introduced to the Ghost Quelling Society, a group of Taoist occultists not unlike the Brody Sisters and company. They are led by a trio of elders (played by Daniel Wu, Byron Mann and Wai Ching Ho), the former and latter of whom Uncle Wahbo vouches for.

episode 5 - "Ghost Quelling Society Ascendant" Chinese plot pt 2. Shockingly, the elder that Uncle Wahbo doesn't know turns out to be in cahoots with the Sphinx Club, who used the Ghost Quelling Society to take out some of their competition, risk free, and then aim to wipe out the Society - they accomplish the former, but not the later, and Priestess Jyutgwai kills the traitor.

episode 6 - "Dust Devils" - dust devils attack Mary and Zidaan as they are traveling through the mountains. Heavy on atmosphere and romantic tension, a little light on plot.

episode 7 - "Encounter at Hangman Hill" - Dinosaur accidentally brought into the present by the Owl Club experimenting with a relic. B-plot with Hannah and Emperor Norton (Michael Emerson, playing the character as a man with a self-aware humor)

episode 8 - "The Infernal Engine" - spiritualism meets science meets Atlantis, Sister Isabel focus. B plot with Zidaan and King Brady trying to convince a fellow gunslinger and Civil War veteran, Hal Wheeler (Clé Bennett), from going after Poole.

episode 9 - "Anglosophy Club" Prompted by a friend (guest star MIchelle Trachtenberg), Hannah joins a new social club only to discover they're diabolical racists. Her protests lead to her being chosen as the next sacrifice, and ironically it's Poole who saves her when he guns down the leaders of the rival club; Hannah's friend survives the episode, but their friendship decidedly does not.

episode 10 - "The Hidden Circle" Maggie and Ambrose Bierce attending a seance. Bierce, unnerved by what he experiences, decamps for England.

episode 11 - "Old Man Mountain" Atlantean tomb pt 1, Mary Burke returns in alliance with the Sphinx Club

episode 12 - "Old Man Mountain" Atlantean tomb pt 2, Mary, somewhat predictably, gets betrayed by her allies and sacrificed in order to open the tomb

Season Three

episode 1 - "The Evil Eye" the Eye of Harun, an ancient Atlantean artifact, the first of three things the Sphinx Club needs in order to become immortal.

episode 2 - "High Society" Hannah-centric episode with Lena Headey as Isabella Bird (real life traveler and writer; her travels in the American West did indeed take place in 1873)

"Shadow of the Ghost" focused on the Zidaans and their rivalry with a street gang with occult shadings, ending with a bloody shoot-out in the back alleys of Chinatown; the B-plot with Isabella Bird and "Savage" Sam Henderson getting quite friendly with each other.is charming but ends on a bittersweet note as Bird moves on to Colorado (in the real life, there was what might have been a fleeting attraction between Bird and the ill-fated Rocky Mountain Jim Nugent)

episode 4 - "The Old Mission" Another Sister Isabel and Maggie adventure, a ghostly nun. Ends with the two of them at St. Eudoxia, lighting candles for her.

In "Fangsm" Bathory returns and targets Maggie, who drives her off without any weapons except her faith. The episode is bookended by two powerful scenes: the opening, where Bathory stalks and devours Jenny, in which her turn from bored flirtation to desperate terror is a powerful performance that ends with her broken, bloodless body being thrown through the windows of Zorzi's, and the finale, where Maggie lays her bare, empty palm on Bathory's forehead and leaves a jagged scar in the shape of a cross, just before the countess bursts into all-consuming white-hot flame.

episode 6 - "Via Crucis" Maggie begins to question her calling, ends with Caoimhe and Tang Wahbo being abducted. Sister Israbel and Archbishop Joseph Sadoc Alemany y Conill (Tony Amendola)

The train starts barreling towards the finale in "The Knife" where Caoimhe and Tang Wahbo are killed by the Clarkes and Poole, and the second of the three artifacts is recovered, too; definitely a low point for our heroes. "Memento Mori" follows three threads: first, the funeral of Tang Wahbo and Caoimhe. second, Anne and Zidaan's failed attempt at revenge, and finally the introduction of Ella-Rae Smith as Martha Brady, King's estranged daughter and aspiring occult investigator.

The aptly titled "Last Call" showcases the end of the line for Zorzi's, as Caterina, traumatized and guilty over Jenny's death, makes tracks for Italy while Violet goes back east; meanwhile, the Sphinx Club locates the third object they need for their sinister plot.

episode 10 - "Tremors" finale pt 1 - tremors

episode 11 - "The Big One" finale pt 2 - the big one, Anne gets her revenge on Gloria and Poole

episode 12 - "Aftershocks" finale pt 3. - aftershocks, the Sphinx Club purged, Anne and Zidaan (and family) bring Uncle Wahbo's body back to China, Maggie takes her vows. King Brady accepts his daughter as an apprentice, and Sam goes back to England - maybe with his eye on a second try with a certain well-mannered traveler....
 
And the first draft is done. Hope someone finds it interesting and/or entertaining!

It's all because of cosplay.

I should have started with Night Mares from day one. The premise - occult investigators in the Old West - is right up my alley, and Molly Quinn was one of my favorite cast members on Castle, so I would have been an easy sell. But for some reason, the show wasn't on my radar until the second season. And we're back to cosplay. One day I was browsing the forums at alternatehistory.com and I happened to wrong-click my way into the "Nice cosplay pictures thread" - there, in between an Emma Frost and the Halo guy, whatever his name is, were a pair of women in old west garb, one a gunslinger with a couple undone buttons on her blouse and the other a mousy-frontier-girl with round spectacles. Apparently, these were the Brophy Sisters. A couple Google searches later and I knew what I wanted to watch while waiting for delivery that night.

Night Mares aired on AMC between 2017 and 2021 with a total of 36 episodes. The titular Night Mares were a secret sisterhood of occult investigators, in this case two Irish-American sisters living in San Francisco in the early 1870s. They delved into paranormal mysteries alongside their friends and allies, often butting heads with the sinister high-society forces of the Sphinx Club. The show drew inspiration from sources such as Stephen King, Manly Wade Wellman and shows like Supernatural and The Adventures of Brisco County Jr. (another Weird Western program, but much, much lighter in tone than Night Mares). The sisters in question, Anne and Maggie Brophy, were played by British actress Emily Beecham in her first major American television role and Molly C. Quinn (fresh off her breakout role on Castle). The rest of the main cast consisted of Lewis Tan as the gunslinger Tang Zidaan, Tania Raymonde as Sister Isabel Ramirez of the fictional Order of St. Victoria, Leighton Meester as Hannah Visser, wealthy socialite and hapless member of the Sphinx Club, Demore Barnes as King Brady, a mostly-friendly rival in the occult troubleshooting business, and Nick Frost as the prospector, brawler and drunkard "Savage" Sam Henderson. They were joined by recurring guest stars Orla Brady (Caoimhe McLarney, Anne's mentor), Morena Baccarin, Leven Rambin and Renee Olstead as Caterina Zorzi, the owner of the bar Zorzi, and her 'girls' Jenny and Violet, Terry O'Quinn and Rachel Nichols as father and daughter Thaddeus and Gloria Clarke, the true rulers of the Sphinx Club, and JuJu Chan, Francois Chau, and James Hong as Taam Jimsan, Zungsam and Wahbo, the sister, father and great-uncle of Tang Zidaan.

While not quite rising to the level of prestige television, Night Mares was one of the better sci-fi/horror shows of the late 2010s, elevated by a great cast and generally smart scripts. It had a modest but devoted fanbase and, mercifully, ended in its own time instead of being prematurely cancelled or, perhaps even worse, staggering a few seasons past its sell-by date. Fans are divided on the overall plot about the Sphinx Club's obsessive hunt for Atlantean relics (hinted at once or twice in season 1 and becoming more and more prominent in the second and third seasons). Speaking only for myself, I thought it was an interesting and (for the most part) well-written storyline, even if one does wonder what Atlantis was doing in California of all places.

Season one introduced the characters, both good and evil, and set them off on their arcs while also laying down the rules of the setting (which the show would do a very good job of adhering to over its run - the showrunners clearly learned from the mistakes of earlier programs we won't mention and had both a plan and a setting bible before the first episode was filmed). The stakes were relatively low-key and most of the plots were solved by the end of a given episode, but as the season went on, we learned more and more about the rot beneath the charming facade of the Sphinx Club until the finale both introduced Max Martini as Tim Poole, cold-blooded killer and the Club's enforcer, and unveiled the previously charming Clarkes as murderous devil-worshipers.

In season two, we were introduced to the Atlantis metaplot that would dominate the show going forward. Night Mares version of Atlantis was rooted into Plato's allegory, but only loosely in that the show's Atlantis was an ancient empire that tried to conquer the entire world (long before Greece or even Egypt existed) before being destroyed - by whom, exactly, the show never really answered (giving rise to both fan theories about Atlantis' enemies and speculation the matter would have been addressed in a fourth season that neither AMC nor the showrunners ever planned on). It culminated in the Sphinx Club locating and plundering an Atlantean tomb, recovering the first of three artifacts the Clarkes needed to achieve their ultimate goal. It also saw significant character growth, especially for Anne and Zidaan, who grew ever closer to each other, and Savage Sam as he left his season one alcoholism and depression well behind.

Everything came to a head in season three, with the Brophies and their allies trying to keep pace with the Sphinx Club even as the Clarkes and Pool steadily picked off their competition as they laid the groundwork for the ritual culmination of their grand plan. There was an increasing air of desperation among the protagonists, not helped by Sister Isabel's crisis of faith and Maggie's existential doubt... before turning the corner in the last five episodes that led up to the tectonic finale and the climactic battle between the Night Mares and the Sphinx Club.

Season One

The first season started with a bang, literally, in the two-part episode "Once Upon a Time in the Weird West" as Anne and Zidaan dynamite a backwoods shack in order to flush out the vampire lurking inside it. We were then introduced to the other main characters and the central location, Zorzi's bar, before the plot whisked along on an adventure involving a haunted mansion outside the city. Part 2 spent most of the time exploring said haunted mansion, allowing the leads to showcase their skills (Anne's intuition, Maggie's book-learning, Zidaan's gunslinging, Sister Isabel's piety and King's keen perception); Lera Lynn, the vocalist for the opening credits, made one of a handful of cameos back at Zorzi's with a poignant performance of "Lorena".

The third episode, "The Sphinx Club", focused on Hannah, a wealthy widow and fixture of San Francisco's social scene, as she joined the titular club and was presented with the first subtle clues it was more sinister than just an exclusive playhouse for the rich and powerful; also notable for the first of a handful of appearances by Ben Browder as Ambrose Bierce.

The follow up, "Haunting at High Noon," saw our heroes explore a ghost town with actual ghosts. It was "Savage" Sam Henderson's first spotlight episode, as he'd once lived in the town and had to come face to face with the literal ghosts of his past, and also the first appearance of the Finnerty Spectacles, a Renaissance device that let the wearer see into the supernatural world.

"The Mentor'' introduced Caoimhe to the show as she helped the Brophies out in dealing with an especially nasty and not-entirely-human murder. It also widened the show's backstory with the implied existence of many more Night Mares both in the States and the Old Country.

Next up was "Midnight in Massacre Canyon," a straightforward episode culminating in a shoot-em-up finale where Anne and Zidaan gun down a horde of zombies The barely-there B-plot involved Maggie and Sister Isabel tracking down a stolen Catholic relic.

In "The Blood Countess" we were introduced to both Elizabeth Bathory (Katja Herbers) and the Convent of St. Eudoxia, where Sister Isabel resides when not investigating the paranormal; the episode had an atypically high body count, as did the next one, "The Wolf of Mariposa County." This time, the principal source of carnage was a gang of werewolves; the b-plot introduced Zidaan's rebellious younger sister Jimsan, who has taught herself martial arts and, naturally, gotten into trouble with the local criminals because of her knight errantry.

The next episode, "Lights on Mount Shasta," was a lot lighter in tone. Hannah hires both Anne and King Brady to investigate the mysterious lights; meanwhile, Jenny seeks Zidaan and Sister Isabel's help on behalf of her brother Jacob, an independent prospector faced with an unearthly problem. In "Terror on the Train," Maggie and Sister Isabel spend the hour on a ritzy Pullman train from San Francisco to Utah; guest starring Florence Pugh as an East Coast ingénue who might not be quite as naïve as she appears.

In "All Soul's Eve" Maggie joins Sister Isabel in assisting Father Shanahan (Scott Foley) in the exorcism of a haunted house in the rich Pacific Heights neighborhood. Meanwhile, Anne and Zidaan investigate rumors of a subterranean cult and run into a pack of feral troglodytes near Tulare Lake. And the season came to a head in "The Talon" where said Talon (Max Martini's Poole) arrived from back east and introduced the Atlantean plot that dominated the show going forward. In the b-plot, a rare comedic turn for the show, Napoleon III and Eugénie, as well as Colonel Zebulon Howell Benton, appear as the former Emperor, seeking to improve his health, has come to California for the climate. Hannah hobnobs with them and accidentally gives offense, ending the imperial interlude in the Bay Area.

Season Two

The season opened with "The Auction" in which an intact Atlantean map up for auction, drew attention from the Clarkes as well as a range of other well-heeled types. Ambrose Bierce appeared again, while Maggie, Sister Isabel and King investigated a haunted mine that turned out to be something of a Scooby Doo. Next was "Goengsi" which was about a Chinese vampire fixated on Hannah for some reason. King Brady and Uncle Wahbo helped resolve the situation. Meanwhile, Anne and Maggie consulted a peculiar old antiquarian (Linda Hunt) about the Atlantean map from the previous episode.

"Devil's Hoof Hill" saw Katie McGrath in a scenery-chewing turn as villainess Mary Burke, seeking to use her supernatural power to become rich and get under Anne's skin. In the b-plot, Sister Isabel consulted with Father Hugh Taunton, a visiting English priest and supernatural expert played by Michael Shanks and based on real-life Jesuit Father Herbert Thurston.
This was followed by the two-part episode "Ghost Quelling Society" in which we were introduced to the Ghost Quelling Society, a group of Taoist occultists not unlike the Brody Sisters and company. They were led by a trio of elders (played by Daniel Wu, Byron Mann and Wai Ching Ho), the former and latter of whom Uncle Wahbo vouched for. Shockingly, the elder that Uncle Wahbo doesn't know turns out to be in cahoots with the Sphinx Club, who used the Ghost Quelling Society to take out some of their competition, risk free, and then aimed to wipe out the Society - they accomplished the former, but not the later, and Priestess Jyutgwai killed the traitor.

In "Dust Devils," Mary and Zidaan were beset by the titutar phenomenon (here said to actually be a minor sort of demonic imp) as they traveled through the mountains east of San Francisco.It was heavy on atmosphere and romantic tension, but a little light on plot. The b-plot involved King and Sam trying to keep up with a visiting gambler (played with panache by Josh Holloway, clearly inspired by Val Kilmer's fantastic Doc Holliday).

Episode seven, "Encounter at Hangman Hill," was a memorable one and a fan favorite. The Sphinx Club, while experimenting with a newly discovered Atlantean device, accidentally summoned a carnivorous dinosaur which ran wild before Poole and Zidaan were able to take the poor confused thing out; the p-lot focused on Hannah having to chaperone the eccentric Emperor Norton (Michael Emerson) for the day. "The Infernal Engine" was an episode with a main plot where spiritualism met science met Atlantis and Sister Isabel had to contend with a mad scientist being employed by the Sphinx Club while Zidaan and King tried to convince a fellow gunslinger and Civil War veteran, Hal Wheeler (Clé Bennett), from going after Poole over a past misdeed.

In "The Anglosophy Club, " Hannah, prompted by a friend (guest star MIchelle Trachtenberg), joined a new social club only to discover they're diabolical racists. Her protests lea to her being chosen as the next sacrifice, and ironically it's Poole who saved her when he gunned down the leaders of the rival club; Hannah's friend survived the episode, but their friendship decidedly did not. Following on that, "The Hidden Circle" saw Maggie and Ambrose Bierce attend a seance organized by Linda Hunt's Miss Greta; Bierce, unnerved by what he experienced, left for England (as he did in reality, presumably not because of supernatural circumstances).

The season ended with a two part episode titled "Old Man Mountain." In it, the Sphinx Club, along with their new friend Mary Burke, explore an Atlantean tomb beneath Old Man Mountain (the Old Man being the occupant of the tomb). Somewhat predictably, Mary was betrayed by her new allies and sacrificed in order to revive the occupant of the tomb - who is soon thereafter blown up thanks to Sam and Zidaan. In the last scene of the season, we see the Clarkes gloating despite their apparent defeat - they got the McGuffin they really wanted.

Season Three

The third and final season kicked off with "The Evil Eye," said eye being the Eye of Harun, an ancient Atlantean artifact and the first of three the leaders of the Sphinx Club need in order to become immortal. Meanwhile, Caoimhe returned with a dire warning from a dream, a dream shared by all the supernaturally attuned characters both good and evil.

"High Society" dialed down the tension a little and was a Hannah-centric episode introducing Lena Headey as Isabella Bird (real life British traveler and writer; her travels in the American West did indeed take place in 1873); sparks flew between her and Savage Sam, while the b-plot dealt with the Brophies and company trying to figure out just what the Sphinx Club's plan was.

Next was "Shadow of the Ghost," which focused on the Zidaans and their rivalry with a street gang with occult shadings, ending with a bloody shoot-out in the back alleys of Chinatown; the B-plot with Isabella Bird and "Savage" Sam Henderson getting quite friendly with each other is charming but ends on a bittersweet note as Bird moves on to Colorado (in the real life, there was what might have been a fleeting attraction between Bird and the ill-fated Rocky Mountain Jim Nugent). Episode four, "The Old Mission," saw Sister Isabel and Maggie teamed up for another adventure, this time involving a ghostly nun, and ended with the two of them at the chapel at St. Eudoxia's convent, lighting candles for her.

In "Fangs," Bathory returned and targeted Maggie, who drove her off without any weapons except her faith. The episode ws bookended by two powerful scenes: the opening, where Bathory stalked and devoured Jenny, in which her turn from bored flirtation to desperate terror was a powerful performance that ended with her broken, bloodless body being thrown through the windows of Zorzi's, and the finale, where Maggie laid her bare, empty palm on Bathory's forehead and left a jagged scar in the shape of a cross, just before the countess burst into all-consuming white-hot flame.

Episode six, "Via Crucis," is a fan favorite where Maggie began to question her calling in the face of all the evil they've encountered, and failed to stop, and ended with Caoimhe and Tang Wahbo being abducted. Meanwhile, Sister Israbel endured a tense series of interviews with Archbishop Joseph Sadoc Alemany (an aristocratic but ultimately sympathetic Tony Amendola) about the supernatural goings on over the past few years. Lera Lynn returns for a haunting rendition of "Stabat Mater."

The train starts barreling towards the finale in "The Knife" where Caoimhe and Tang Wahbo are killed by the Clarkes and Poole, and the second of the three artifacts is recovered, too; definitely a low point for our heroes. "Memento Mori" follows three threads: first, the funeral of Tang Wahbo and Caoimhe. second, Anne and Zidaan's failed attempt at revenge, and finally the introduction of Ella-Rae Smith as Martha Brady, King's estranged daughter and aspiring occult investigator. The aptly titled "Last Call" showcases the end of the line for Zorzi's, as Caterina, traumatized and guilty over Jenny's death, makes tracks for Italy while Violet goes back east; meanwhile, the Sphinx Club locates the third object they need for their sinister plot.

And at last, we reach the grand finale, a three-part story that wraps everything up with a bang. It begins in "Tremors" where our heroes, their backs to the wall, try everything they could think of to get a leg up on the Sphinx Club, by now brazenly secure in their own power and unafraid even of the California militia and the Church. "Only a miracle can save us now," a dispirited Anne said towards the end of the episode, after she failed in her attempt to gun down Poole and Gloria Clarke. "Then we'll have to ask God for one," Sister Isabel said just before the ground began to shake and the credits rolled. Part two was "The Big One" and it delivered on what the title promised. A major earthquake strikes the city, causing panic and mayhem, but also an opportunity, as our heroes realized the physical and paranormal protections around the Sphinx Club are likely to be as tattered as the rest of the city. They gathered what was left of their allies and launched an all-out attack on the clubhouse, leading to a very well-choreographed series of battle scenes pushing ever deeper down into the maze below the club. And finally comes "Aftershocks" which at long last has the Clarkes and Pool brought to justice, Old West style, as their ritual is disrupted just in time and all three are consumed by the hellfire machine they sought to use to become immortal. With the Sphinx Club purged, Anne and Zidaan (and family) bring Uncle Wahbo's body back to China, Maggie takes her vows. Hannah becomes the head of a new (and decidedly less evil, one hopes) occult social club called the Phoenix Club, King accepts his daughter as an apprentice, and Sam goes back to England - maybe with his eye on a second try with a certain well-mannered traveler. The credits roll with a reprise of "Stabat Mater" and so we bid farewell to the Night Mares.
 
Fun (?) fact - there is an actual POD here, if an implicit and obscure one. Consult the Wikipedia or IMDB pages of the three British lead actors…
 
This is surprisingly interesting I can really imagine this show being a thing, it seems like something from the early 2000s but somewhat better than a lot of what was on offer.
 
Of course you need at least one episode that is bad and regressive and turns out to have been written by someone who wrote the same awful script in three other major sci-fi shows.

It breaks my suspension of disbelief for this not to happen.

The A-plot of Dust Devils was intended to nod in that direction. There was originally an episode with Sasquatches, too, but it got pruned early on.
 
Back
Top