• Hi Guest!

    The costs of running this forum are covered by Sea Lion Press. If you'd like to help support the company and the forum, visit patreon.com/sealionpress

Least favorite alt-history story?

Burton K Wheeler

The G.O.A.T. That Can't Be Got
Location
Tr'ondëk
I read that TL years ago and for a time corresponded with rvbomally a fair bit. If memory serves, the chain of logic is not "black people getting rights -> space dystopia."

Rather his emphasis is on the fact that in order to achieve radical reconstruction the US government must use the Army to a much greater extent than it did in OTL. This leads to the military having a much larger role in American politics, eventually becoming something akin to a Latin American military junta. It is this much more authoritarian country that becomes a world power by that universe’s version of the Cold War.

I’m certain the more knowledgeable could poke holes in that logic, and there’s a fair argument that it’s problematic, but I never got the impression it was a deliberately racist screed.
I feel like Good Thing Has Bad Consequences is, or at least should be, one of the basic themes of alternate history.
 

theev

Las Vegas is a society of armed masturbators
Pronouns
he/him
Just had this (and several, shall we, say right-wing fantasies by the same author to my bemusement) "recommended" to me by Amazon. I'm almost tempted to spend the $4 to see if it's as dumb as the blurb suggests.
Ah yes, Ira Tabankin is perhaps the most prolific of conservative pulled-from-the-headlines speculative fiction writers.
 

Burton K Wheeler

The G.O.A.T. That Can't Be Got
Location
Tr'ondëk
It is one of the main moralistic themes already, otl is the best possible world and any attempt to improve it will end in disaster
Or something like that
That's a lot of it, but I was thinking of it more as a simple demonstration of how complex history is, or more specifically if it's an area of history you know about. The bad guys winning WWII and the ACW aren't really interesting scenarios, but as an American it's interesting to think of what a different America they would lead to. TL-191's Prussian America and AANW's version of the Eisenhower/JFK liberal consensus on steroids are much more interesting than the fact that there is more slavery and a worse Holocaust in those scenarios.
 

Gary Oswald

Old and Foolish now
Sea Lion Press staff
Published by SLP
Pronouns
he/him
I think my least favorite AH is the one where Chris Chan becomes a school shooter
Jesus.

There's always been an undercurrent of AH as personal attack on people you don't like, see 'Dominion' and 'the SNP will collaborate with the nazis just like they are now' or 'Rodham' and 'wouldn't hilary be better off if she just hadn't married that stinking Bill' but that's a new level.
 

Hendryk

Nothing ever ends
Published by SLP
Location
France
There's always been an undercurrent of AH as personal attack on people you don't like, see 'Dominion' and 'the SNP will collaborate with the nazis just like they are now' or 'Rodham' and 'wouldn't hilary be better off if she just hadn't married that stinking Bill' but that's a new level.
There was one where Ian Montgomerie becomes a UN political commissar and rigidly enforces ideological conformity on the protagonists, who, as freedom-loving straight white males, obviously chafe under the yoke of global socialism or something. I forgot the details.
 
Top