• Hi Guest!

    The costs of running this forum are covered by Sea Lion Press. If you'd like to help support the company and the forum, visit patreon.com/sealionpress

aaa's bad memory palace

1974–1976: Tommy Douglas (New Democratic)
Feb. 1974 def. Robert Stanfield (Progressive Conservative), Paul Hellyer (Liberal), René Levesque (Parti National)
Oct. 1974 def. Robert Stanfield (Progressive Conservative), Paul Hellyer (Liberal), René Levesque (Parti National)

1976–1979: David Lewis (New Democratic)
1979–1990: Flora MacDonald (Progressive Conservative)

1979 def. David Lewis (New Democratic), John Turner (Liberal)
1983 def. Mel Watkins (New Democratic), John Turner (Liberal)
1987 def. Ed Broadbent (New Democratic), John Turner (Liberal)

1990–1997: Brian Mulroney (Progressive Conservative)
1992 def. Ed Broadbent (New Democratic), Jean Chrétien (Liberal)
1997–2007: Jack Layton (New Democratic)
1997 def. Brian Mulroney (Progressive Conservative), Jean Chrétien (Liberal)
2001 def. Brian Pallister (Progressive Conservative), Sheila Copps (Liberal)
2005 def. Vic Toews (Progressive Conservative), Sheila Copps (Liberal)

2007–2010: Robert Chisholm (New Democratic)
2010–2016: Scott Brison (Progressive Conservative-Liberal coalition, then Progressive Conservative)

2010 def. Robert Chisholm (New Democratic), Justin Trudeau (Liberal)
2015 def. Peter Julian (New Democratic), Martine Ouellet (Parti National), Justin Trudeau (Liberal)

2016–2019: Alison Redford (Progressive Conservative)
2017 def. Alexandre Boulerice (New Democratic), Martine Ouellet (Parti National), Stéphane Dion (Liberal)
2019–0000: Kevin O'Leary (Progressive Conservative)
2019 def. Alexandre Boulerice (New Democratic), Martine Ouellet (Parti National), Mélanie Joly (Liberal)
 
The only natural course of action after learning that Liz Truss's parents were "to the left of Labour" and her own father refused to campaign for her.

1979–1983: Margaret Thatcher (Conservative)
1979 def. James Callaghan (Labour), David Steel (Liberal)
1983–1990: Michael Foot (Labour)
1983 def. Margaret Thatcher (Conservative), David Steel & Roy Jenkins (Liberal-SDP Alliance)
1988 (min.) def. Jim Prior (Conservative), David Steel & Bill Rodgers (Liberal-SDP Alliance)

1990–2003: Michael Heseltine (Conservative)
1990 def. Michael Foot (Labour), Bill Rodgers (SLD), David Owen (Democratic)
1995 def. Ken Livingstone (Labour), Dick Taverne (SLD), David Owen (Democratic)
2000 (coalition with SLD) def. Dawn Primarolo (Labour), Menzies Campbell (SLD), David Owen & Rosie Barnes (Democratic)

2003–2005: Andrew Lansley (Conservative)
2005–2010: Mark Drakeford (Labour)

2005 def. Andrew Lansley (Conservative), Menzies Campbell (SLD)
2010–2018: Alan Duncan (Conservative)
2010 (min.) def. Mark Drakeford (Labour), Dick Newby (SLD), Jeffrey Titford (National)
2013 def. Mark Drakeford (Labour), Tom Brake (SLD), Jacob Rees-Mogg (National)

2018–0000: Elizabeth Truss (Labour)
2018 def. Alan Duncan (Conservative), Tim Farron (SLD), Jacob Rees-Mogg (National)
 
The only natural way to unite the left and defeat Macron, Le Pen, and Zemmour. Et voila, le coseil de la république.

51810651075_ed0f6cbfef_o.png
 
Last edited:
The only natural course of action after learning that Liz Truss's parents were "to the left of Labour" and her own father refused to campaign for her.

1979–1983: Margaret Thatcher (Conservative)
1979 def. James Callaghan (Labour), David Steel (Liberal)
1983–1990: Michael Foot (Labour)
1983 def. Margaret Thatcher (Conservative), David Steel & Roy Jenkins (Liberal-SDP Alliance)
1988 (min.) def. Jim Prior (Conservative), David Steel & Bill Rodgers (Liberal-SDP Alliance)

1990–2003: Michael Heseltine (Conservative)
1990 def. Michael Foot (Labour), Bill Rodgers (SLD), David Owen (Democratic)
1995 def. Ken Livingstone (Labour), Dick Taverne (SLD), David Owen (Democratic)
2000 (coalition with SLD) def. Dawn Primarolo (Labour), Menzies Campbell (SLD), David Owen & Rosie Barnes (Democratic)

2003–2005: Andrew Lansley (Conservative)
2005–2010: Mark Drakeford (Labour)

2005 def. Andrew Lansley (Conservative), Menzies Campbell (SLD)
2010–2018: Alan Duncan (Conservative)
2010 (min.) def. Mark Drakeford (Labour), Dick Newby (SLD), Jeffrey Titford (National)
2013 def. Mark Drakeford (Labour), Tom Brake (SLD), Jacob Rees-Mogg (National)

2018–0000: Elizabeth Truss (Labour)
2018 def. Alan Duncan (Conservative), Tim Farron (SLD), Jacob Rees-Mogg (National)

51846348789_89ea7a9c28_o.png
 
Last edited:
Here's another adaptation of a list game from one of my Discord servers. PMs and tenures were collaborative; elections, party systems, and other party leaders were by me.

List of Prime Ministers of the United Kingdom

1908–1918: Herbert Henry Asquith (Liberal)

Jan. 1910 (min.) def. Arthur Balfour (Conservative), Arthur Henderson (Labour)
Dec. 1910 def. Arthur Balfour (Conservative), George Barnes (Labour)
1915 def. Austen Chamberlain (Conservative), George Barnes (Democratic Labour), George Lansbury (Independent Labour)

1918–1922: Austen Chamberlain (Conservative)
1918 def. Herbert Henry Asquith (Liberal), George Barnes (Democratic Labour), George Lansbury (Independent Labour)
1922–1927: Sir John Simon (Liberal)
1922 def. Austen Chamberlain (Conservative), Ramsay MacDonald (Democratic Labour), Arthur Henderson (Independent Labour)
1927–1935: Sir Austen Chamberlain (Conservative)
1927 (min.) def. Sir John Simon (Liberal), Ramsay MacDonald (Democratic Labour), Tom Johnston (Independent Labour)
1929 def. Sir Herbert Samuel (Liberal), William Jowitt (Democratic Labour), Tom Johnston (Independent Labour)

1935–1935: Sir Samuel Hoare (Conservative)
1935–1937: Sir Herbert Samuel (Liberal)

1935 (min. with Democratic Labour support) def. Sir Samuel Hoare (Conservative), William Jowitt (Democratic Labour), James Maxton (Independent Labour)
1937–1940: Noel Skelton (Conservative) †
1937 def. Sir Herbert Samuel (Liberal), Ernest Bevin (Democratic Labour), James Maxton (Independent Labour)
1940–1945: Leo Amery (Conservative)
1941 def. Sir Herbert Samuel (Liberal), Ernest Bevin (Democratic Labour), James Maxton (Independent Labour)
1945–1947: Sir Herbert Samuel (Liberal)
1945 (coalition with Democratic Labour) def. Leo Amery (Conservative), Ernest Bevin (Democratic Labour), Fenner Brockway (Independent Labour)
1947–1958: Sir Archibald Sinclair, 4th Baronet (Liberal)
1948 def. Oliver Stanley (Conservative), Malcolm MacDonald (Democratic Labour), Fenner Brockway (Independent Labour)
1951 def. Harold Nicolson (Conservative), Malcolm MacDonald (Democratic Labour), Tom Wintringham (Independent Labour)
1956 def. Sir Anthony Eden (Conservative), Philip Noel-Baker (Democratic Labour), Tom Wintringham (Independent Labour)

1958–1967: Duncan Sandys (Conservative)
1958 def. Sir Archibald Sinclair, 4th Baronet (Liberal), Herbert Morrison (Democratic Labour), John Freeman (Independent Labour)
1963 def. Sir Dingle Foot, 2nd Baronet & Harold Wilson (Liberal-Democratic Labour Alliance), John Collins (Independent Labour)

1967–1975: Harold Wilson (Liberal)
1967 def. Duncan Sandys (Conservative)
1972 def. Edward du Cann (Conservative)

1975–1989: Roy Jenkins (Liberal)
1977 def. Edward du Cann (Conservative)
1982 def. Airey Neave (Conservative)
1987 def. Paul Channon (Conservative)

1989–1997: Tony Benn, 2nd Viscount Stansgate (Liberal)
1992 def. Bill Newton Dunn (Conservative)
1997–2000: Dame Margaret Beckett (Liberal)
1997 (min.) def. Robert Gascoyne-Cecil, Viscount Cranborne (New Democratic)
2000–2011: Iain Duncan Smith (New Democratic)
2000 def. Dame Margaret Beckett (Liberal)
2005 def. Jane Bonham Carter (Liberal)
2008 (min.) def. Alistair Darling (Liberal)

2011–2016: Catherine Ashton (Liberal)
2011 def. Iain Duncan Smith (New Democratic)
2016–2021: Richard Plunkett-Ernle-Erle-Drax (New Democratic)
2016 def. Catherine Ashton (Liberal)
2021–2022: Chris Grayling (Liberal)
2021 def. Richard Plunkett-Ernle-Erle-Drax (New Democratic)
2022–2022: David Alton (Liberal) (acting)
2022–0000: Rishi Sunak (Liberal)

2022 def. Nigella Lawson (New Democratic)
 
So, next on my list of ideas—one of the crazier ones, obviously—was this: a list of Canadian PMs but it's only people who have served in the Senate. Here goes.

1968–1976: Duff Roblin (Progressive Conservative)
1968 def. Paul Hellyer (Liberal), Tommy Douglas (New Democratic), Réal Caouette (Ralliement créditiste)
1972 def. Paul Martin (Liberal), Tommy Douglas (New Democratic)

1976–1976: Claude Wagner (Progressive Conservative)
1976–1983: Allan MacEachen (Liberal)

1976 (min.) def. Claude Wagner (Progressive Conservative), Charles Taylor (New Democratic)
1978 def. Peter Lougheed (Progressive Conservative), Charles Taylor (New Democratic)

1983–1985: Roméo LeBlanc (Liberal)
1983 (min.) def. Peter Lougheed (Progressive Conservative), Edward Schreyer (New Democratic)
1985–1988: Pat Carney (Progressive Conservative)
1985 (min.) def. Roméo LeBlanc (Liberal), Dave Barrett (New Democratic)
1988–1992: Roméo LeBlanc (Liberal)
1988 def. Pat Carney (Progressive Conservative), Dave Barrett (New Democratic)
1992–1999: Elaine McCoy (Progressive Conservative)
1992 def. Roméo LeBlanc (Liberal), Bob Rae (New Democratic)
1997 def. Bob Rae (New Democratic), Daniel Johnson Jr. (Liberal)

1999–2002: Pierre Claude Nolin (Progressive Conservative)
2002–2014: Roméo Dallaire (Liberal)

2002 (min.) def. Pierre Claude Nolin (Progressive Conservative), Ujjal Dosanjh (New Democratic)
2004 def. Ujjal Dosanjh (New Democratic), Mike Harris (Progressive Conservative)
2009 def. Larry Smith (Progressive Conservative), Ujjal Dosanjh (New Democratic)

2014–2019: Larry Smith (Progressive Conservative)
2014 def. Roméo Dallaire (Liberal), Olivia Chow (New Democratic)
2019–0000: Frances Larkin (New Democratic)
2019 (min. with Liberal support) def. Larry Smith (Progressive Conservative), Frank Baylis (Liberal)
 
The only natural course of action after learning that Liz Truss's parents were "to the left of Labour" and her own father refused to campaign for her.

1979–1983: Margaret Thatcher (Conservative)
1979 def. James Callaghan (Labour), David Steel (Liberal)
1983–1990: Michael Foot (Labour)
1983 def. Margaret Thatcher (Conservative), David Steel & Roy Jenkins (Liberal-SDP Alliance)
1988 (min.) def. Jim Prior (Conservative), David Steel & Bill Rodgers (Liberal-SDP Alliance)

1990–2003: Michael Heseltine (Conservative)
1990 def. Michael Foot (Labour), Bill Rodgers (SLD), David Owen (Democratic)
1995 def. Ken Livingstone (Labour), Dick Taverne (SLD), David Owen (Democratic)
2000 (coalition with SLD) def. Dawn Primarolo (Labour), Menzies Campbell (SLD), David Owen & Rosie Barnes (Democratic)

2003–2005: Andrew Lansley (Conservative)
2005–2010: Mark Drakeford (Labour)

2005 def. Andrew Lansley (Conservative), Menzies Campbell (SLD)
2010–2018: Alan Duncan (Conservative)
2010 (min.) def. Mark Drakeford (Labour), Dick Newby (SLD), Jeffrey Titford (National)
2013 def. Mark Drakeford (Labour), Tom Brake (SLD), Jacob Rees-Mogg (National)

2018–0000: Elizabeth Truss (Labour)
2018 def. Alan Duncan (Conservative), Tim Farron (SLD), Jacob Rees-Mogg (National)
The Thatcher administration absolutely bungles the crisis in the Falklands, demoralizing the British people and highlighting growing problems at home, not least a rising recession and increased costs of living. Labour, promising a revitalization of government services, more active intervention in the financial sector, and the removal of hereditary peers from the Lords, win a landslide, sending Michael Foot into Number 10. Foot, perhaps the most radical prime minister since Attlee, started out with high approval ratings, mostly due to the stark contrast with the failing Thatcher ministry. Thatcher soon resigns and the Tories, all too aware of the dismal public perception of the "dries," elect leading "wet" Jim Prior to lead them in opposition. Foot's proposal to leave the EEC, however, fails to take off as whips inform him that there are simply too many pro-Europeans within the PLP.

Prior and his shadow cabinet are able to repair much of the public damage, with Shadow Home Secretary Nicholas Scott and Shadow Foreign Secretary Lord Carrington (now an elected MP after the revocation of his Lords seat) effectively promoting viable and popular alternatives to Foot's radicalism. Pollsters and forecasters predict a pure tossup in the 1988 election, with Labour ultimately coming out on top but with their majority cut down to a handful of seats. Prior is still extremely popular with both the Conservative membership and the public, but he opts to retire to the backbenches and the Tories elect ("wet") Shadow Chancellor Michael Heseltine over ("dry") Shadow Energy Secretary Nigel Lawson in a landslide.

After Foot successfully undoes much of Thatcher's deregulation agenda and lowers the cost of living, the country's gradually turns against him as he seeks to enact his more ambitious policy plans, such as the complete abolition of the British nuclear weapons program. With his majority severely slimmed down. Foot decides to make a gambit by calling a snap election for 1990. Heseltine, already broadly popular, is able to successfully position himself as the sensible, moderate, and stable choice for prime minister, and the Tories win a substantial majority and a clear mandate to govern. Despite Foot's unyielding republicanism and distaste for nobility, the Queen, who took a personal liking to Foot even prior to his premiership, offers him the Order of the Garter. Though he initially protested, he eventually accepted the knighthood at the persuasion of the Queen Mother, who became close friends with Foot towards the end of his premiership.

Enter the 1990s, the decade of the moderate center-right. Thatcherism firmly behind them, the Tories set out to set out the one-nation vision of Disraeli, Macmillan, Butler, Heath, and now Heseltine. Meanwhile, Labour elects Gordon Brown to succeed Foot (over Neil Kinnock and John Maxton), while the newly-united Social and Liberal Democrats first elect SDP leader Bill Rodgers then fellow Labour-SDP defector Dick Taverne to lead their growing party. With large sections of both the Conservatives and Labour (the latter previously held back by Foot's cautious Euroscepticism) backing some degree of European integration—and the SDP already staunchly in favor—Heseltine swiftly sends Foreign Secretary Tim Sainsbury to Brussels to participate in talks about the formation of a common European currency. Once the EU announces the launch of the new European Currency Unit (ECU), there is a broad consensus in Britain in favor of adopting it, and the three party leaders often stand side-by-side at events promoting the ECU.

The Conservative government is easily re-elected in 1995, but opposition gains at the hands of Dawn Primarolo and Menzies Campbell reduce Heseltine's government down to a minority in 2000. As a result, he decides to form a coalition with Campbell's SLDs, with Campbell being appointed Deputy Prime Minister and the party receiving handful of ministerial posts to dole out. Heseltine finally decides to retire in 2003, shortly after eclipsing Salisbury to become the fourth longest-serving prime minister in history. He is succeeded by deputy party leader Andrew Lansley, who is swiftly elected leader without opposition. When 2005 comes along, the electorate seems tired of the Tory government, and Labour's Mark Drakeford wins a majority.

Drakeford's term is largely uneventful: he presides over the creation of devolved parliaments for Scotland and Wales, organizes reforms to allow absolute primogeniture for the British monarchy, enhances local government reforms enacted under Foot and Heseltine, and organizes former Labour leader Gordon Brown's (ultimately successful) campaign to be Britain's first European Commission president. Labour loses the 2010 election in an upset to the Tories, and Alan Duncan, Britain's first openly gay prime minister, forms a minority government. Much less ECU-friendly than the Europhilic Heseltine, Duncan calls a snap election in 2013 and successfully rides a wave of economic populism to win a majority. This backfires, however, when a 2015 referendum to abandon the ECU in favor of a decimalized pound is rejected, 57-43, severely weakening Duncan's popularity.

Enter Liz Truss. The daughter of Labour activists and staunch supporters of Michael Foot, she cut her teeth with the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament, eventually becoming president of the Oxford University Labour Club. After working as a parliamentary staffer and adviser to Dawn Primarolo, Truss won election to the constituency of Hemsworth. Describing herself as an "unrepentant Footite," she won a close race against Cherie Blair to replace Drakeford as Labour leader and ran the 2018 campaign on a progressive, socialist, and pro-European (which Foot had become in his later years) platform. When the polls closed on the first of December, 2018, it appeared as though Britain would have a second female prime minister after almost 35 years—although she would be the polar opposite of the first.
 
Last edited:
Labour loses the 2010 election in an upset to the Tories, and Alan Duncan, Britain's first openly gay prime minister, forms a minority government. Much less ECU-friendly than the Europhilic Heseltine, Duncan calls a snap election in 2013 and successfully rides a wave of economic populism to win a majority. This backfires, however, when a 2015 referendum to abandon the ECU in favor of a decimalized pound is rejected, 57-43, severely weakening Duncan's popularity.
Oooh nice use of Alan Duncan there, it would make sense for him to be leader in a marginally more Left Wing Britain (combining Thatcherite economics with a more socially Liberal attitude ala Michael Portillo). Fun list (though I’m never a fan of Michael Foot winning in the early 80s, always think it would have been better if he was in office in 1976).
Here's another adaptation of a list game from one of my Discord servers. PMs and tenures were collaborative; elections, party systems, and other party leaders were by me.
I do think there would still be a place for a Left Wing Third Party going from the 1960s, as I remember hearing that even Communist Candidates in Council Elections would often gain votes from Conservative Voters if it was a two ballot system because they liked the guy and his ideas.

Additionally a world where Britain is divided between Liberals and Conservative’s seems like a place where a Centrist Populist Social Credit Party would appear.
 
Oooh nice use of Alan Duncan there, it would make sense for him to be leader in a marginally more Left Wing Britain (combining Thatcherite economics with a more socially Liberal attitude ala Michael Portillo).
That was the goal! I figured Portillo was a bit of a cliche and it'd be fun as well to have an openly gay PM.

Fun list (though I’m never a fan of Michael Foot winning in the early 80s, always think it would have been better if he was in office in 1976).
Fair enough; honestly my main reason for making this list was to have a hard-left Labour PM Liz Truss so I didn't want to go too far back for the PoD.

I do think there would still be a place for a Left Wing Third Party going from the 1960s, as I remember hearing that even Communist Candidates in Council Elections would often gain votes from Conservative Voters if it was a two ballot system because they liked the guy and his ideas.

Additionally a world where Britain is divided between Liberals and Conservative’s seems like a place where a Centrist Populist Social Credit Party would appear.
Definitely makes sense; part of me wanted to have the Independent Labour Party continue on but what I was going for was that the Liberal Party eventually positions itself as a big tent of the left, encompassing everyone from moderate liberals to socialists (hence leaders such as Beckett and Lord Stansgate). Social Credit seems like an interesting idea but frankly I know very little about the movement so I don't normally add them to my lists.
 
That was the goal! I figured Portillo was a bit of a cliche and it'd be fun as well to have an openly gay PM.
Yeah, I do like Portillo as a ‘reaction to the Kinnockite Consensus’ in a 91’/92’ Kinnock victory stuff but that’s his extent and he would probably be replaced Lansley or Hague in time.

Fair enough; honestly my main reason for making this list was to have a hard-left Labour PM Liz Truss so I didn't want to go too far back for the PoD.
Oh it’s just personal preference really, I just think in 1983, Foot is a bit too old personally.
Definitely makes sense; part of me wanted to have the Independent Labour Party continue on but what I was going for was that the Liberal Party eventually positions itself as a big tent of the left, encompassing everyone from moderate liberals to socialists (hence leaders such as Beckett and Lord Stansgate). Social Credit seems like an interesting idea but frankly I know very little about the movement so I don't normally add them to my lists.
I would say like Canada there would be a place of the Trade Union Left or even a Cooperative heavy party as it were. Additionally Social Credit is broad (there’s a good article on the blog about it) but in Britain it was a kind of a Centrist EcoNationalist movement based in a British Folk/Agricultural Revival movement of sorts.

It was a strange beast (imagine it would be the party of Teddie Goldsmith and Des Wilson).
 
I would say like Canada there would be a place of the Trade Union Left or even a Cooperative heavy party as it were. Additionally Social Credit is broad (there’s a good article on the blog about it) but in Britain it was a kind of a Centrist EcoNationalist movement based in a British Folk/Agricultural Revival movement of sorts.

It was a strange beast (imagine it would be the party of Teddie Goldsmith and Des Wilson).
Definitely makes sense that a party like this would spring up in a liberal-conservative party system, but methinks it'd have to be very different from the historical UK SoCred party or else it'd never enter the political mainstream.
 
Definitely makes sense that a party like this would spring up in a liberal-conservative party system, but methinks it'd have to be very different from the historical UK SoCred party or else it'd never enter the political mainstream.
We you could have it one of two ways;

Have it be like the NZ SocCred party, an entity of Liberal Democrat Non of the Above type Anti-Establishment Politics with a Centre-Left wonky base (possible that someone like Oliver Baldwin or Harold Macmillan could start this) or like Canada’s one, a coalition of various different Centre-Right Populists of various stripes.

Additionally you definitely could have a British Social Credit be like Canada’s Social Credit, uniting Anti-Establishment, Nationalist and SocCreds folks together under a Centre-Right Populist banner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aaa
just no words to describe just how beautiful this is. i mean it. both in terms of content and the wikibox itself. if you've thought about it at all - who ends up replacing trebek as host of jeopardy ITTL?
 
  • Like
Reactions: aaa
Back
Top