1893-1897:
John M. Palmer (Democratic)
'92 (with William Eustis Russell) def. Benjamin Harrison (Republican) and James B. Weaver (People's)
1897-1900:
Cushman K. Davis (Republican & People's)
'96 (with Marion Butler) def. John M. Palmer (Democratic) and Levi P. Morton (National Republican)
'00 (with Marion Butler) def. George Dewey (Democratic & National Republican)
1900-1905:
Marion Butler (Republican)
Replaced Davis
1905-1908:
William Freeman Vilas (Democratic)
'04 (with George Gray) def. Richard F. Pettigrew (Republican)
'08 (with George Gray) def. Albert B. Cummins (Republican)
1908-1913:
George Gray (Democratic)
Replaced Vilas
1913-1921:
Thomas H. Carter (Republican)
'12 (with Nahum Josiah Bachelder) def. George Gray (Democratic)
'16 (with Nahum Josiah Bachelder) def. Simeon Eben Baldwin (Democratic)
1921-1929:
Edward I. Edwards (Democratic)
'20 (with J. Campbell Cantrill) def. Nahum Josiah Bachelder (Republican)
'24 (with Albert Ritchie) def. Jacob S. Coxey Sr. (Republican)
1929-1933:
Royal Copeland (Democratic)
'28 (with Vic Donahey) def. George Norris (Republican)
1933-1937:
Smith Wildman Brookhart (Republican)
'32 (with Homer Bone) def. Royal Copeland (Democratic)
1937-1941:
Charles H. Martin (Democratic)
'36 (with Thomas Rhea) def. Smith Wildman Brookhart (Republican)
1940:
Smedley Butler (Republican)
'40 (with John L. Lewis) def. Charles H. Martin / Thomas Rhea (Democratic)
1941-1945:
John L. Lewis (Republican)
Replaced Butler
1945-1949:
Henry J. Kaiser (Democratic)
'44 (with Frederick Van Nuys) def. John L. Lewis (Republican)
1949-1959:
Bill Langer (Republican)
'48 (with Huey Long) def. Henry J. Kaiser (Democratic) and Robert Taft (Liberty & ‘Isolationist’ Democratic)
'52 (with Huey Long) def. Paul A. Dever (Democratic) and Robert Taft (Liberty)
'56 (with Wayne Morse) def. Manchester Boddy (Democratic) and William E. Jenner (Liberty)
1959-1961:
Wayne Morse (Republican)
Replaced Langer
1961-1965:
Harold J. Arthur (Republican)
'60 (with Jeremiah Voorhis) def. Joseph P. Kennedy Jr. (Democratic & Liberty) and Paul Douglas (Independent)
1965-1969:
Nelson Rockefeller (Democratic)
'64 (with Malcolm Buie Seawell) def. Harold J. Arthur (Republican)
1969-1977:
Billy Graham (Republican)
'68 (with Harold Hughes) def. Nelson Rockefeller (Democratic)
'72 (with Harold Hughes) def. Henry M. Jackson (Democratic)
1977-1979:
James Hoffa (Republican)
'76 (with George McGovern) def. Alphonzo E. Bell Jr. (Democratic)
1979-1981:
George McGovern (Republican)
Replaced Hoffa
1981-1989:
Jack Kemp (Democratic)
'80 (with ) def. George McGovern (Republican)
'84 (with ) def. Jim Luken (Republican)
1989-1993:
Anthony Iacocca (Democratic)
'88 (with Paul Tsongas) def.
1993-1997:
David Garst (Republican)
1992 (with Bronson La Follette) def. Anthony Iacocca (Democratic)
1997-2005:
Norman Schwarzkopf (Independent & Democratic)
1996 (with John Engler) def. David Garst (Republican)
2000 (with John Engler) def. Glen Stassen (Republican)
2005-2017:
Billy Blythe (Republican)
2004 (with ) def. Norman Schwarzkopf (Independent) and Hillary Trump (Democratic)
2008 (with ) def. Isadore Lieberman (Democratic)
2012 (with ) def. Liz Herring (Democratic)
2017-2021:
Betsy Huber (Republican)
2016 (with John Boyd Jr.) def. Dick Zimmer (Democratic)
2021-Present:
Frederick Lee Morton (Democratic)
2020 (with Curtis Sliwa) def. Betsy Huber (Republican)