• Hi Guest!

    The costs of running this forum are covered by Sea Lion Press. If you'd like to help support the company and the forum, visit patreon.com/sealionpress

doctor who alternate history megathread

for all imaginary alternate who stuff!
scenario 1
pertwee season 12
1. Robot
2. Ark in space ( John Lucroatti Version)
3.Revenge Of The Cybermen (same title different story set entirely on Voga)
4.the wendigo ( new story with alien twist on classic beast written by Phillip Hintchiffe)
5. Return of the Spiders (Pertwee regenerates to Ian McDiarmind)
Mcdiarmind Season 13
1.Genesis of the Daleks
2. The Beast In the Mist ( new story featuring alien dinosaur-Harry leaves)
3. The Sontaran Investigation ( set in England 1601 the doctor and Sarah prevent queen liz from getting killed by the Sontarans)
4. The Secret of Morbius (Brain of Morbius otl)
5.The Stone Army (terracotta warriors come to life under alien influence)
6. The Lost Legion (Based on otl unmade story Sarah gets killed)
Mcdiarmind Season 14
1. Flight Of The Comet (introduces Wanda Venthams's commander Juliet Lewis)
2. Image Of The Fendhal
3. The Plague Of Death (OTL'S survivors series backdoor pilot by Terry Nation)
4. The Pescatons
5. Phyrric Victory (Phyrrus pure historical)
6. Pyramids Of Mars
Mcdiarmind season 15
1. The Mandragora Helix
2.Eldrad Must Live
3. The Secret Of Gabriel Chase (OTL's Ghost Light made Earlier)
4. The Time Train ( a bit like the chase in that multiple time periods are visited
5. Phantoms Of the Planet ( Planet Of Evil Retitled)
6. Land Of The Dead ( the Master played by Geoffrey Palmer Debuts)
McDiarmind season 16
1. Revolt on Ribos
2. Horror On Fang Rock
3. The Horns of Nimon (Gareth Hunt as Seth joins the crew)
4. Return Of the Monk
( introducing Graham Chapman as the Monk, set in Moscow 1917 during Russian Revolution also starring Tom Baker as Rasputin)
5. The Graveyard of Tardises (15th anniversary story with Jon Pertwee and Geoffrey Palmer returning in their respective roles)
6. The Law Machines (set on a planet where the law is enforced by robots in a Sun-Makers styled episode)

McDiarmind season 17
1. The Creature From The Pit
2. The Power Of Kroll
3. The Shield Of Zarak
4. The Vampire Mutations
5. Enchantress Of Numbers
6. Helm Of Awe (different story then the big finish one, set on a alien planet with a mystical mcguffin that they have to find)
7. How Does You're Garden Grow (Queen Mary pure historical not the plot of Marian Conspiracy)
8. The Tearing Of The Veil ( Juliet Lewis gets killed by the episodes antagonist)
Last edited:

Charles EP M.

Well-known member
Published by SLP
or Colin Baker not getting fired in 1986
That one would mean John Nathan-Turner goes instead - as this was Michael Grade's demand, assuming JN-T wouldn't - so this has a huge change. For one thing, there's no Andrew Cartmel because he was JN-T's hire; for another, how many of the S24-26 writers would get their shot without JN-T (who boosted new writers) and Cartmel, and what would their stories look like if not for the Cartmel Masterplan? Severely unlikely someone as new as Ben Aaronovitch is going to be writing a big Dalek story!
8th: Paul McGann (1996-1999)
9th: Bradley Whitford (1999-2003)
10th Bradley Cooper (2003-2008)
11th: Wendie Malick (2008-2012)
12th Seth McFarlane (2012-2016)
13th Kal Penn (2017-2019) (cancelled due to low ratings)

animated reboot
14TH Patricia Summersett (2023-)

8/25/21 retcon the show is is no longer cancelled then revived, instead after McFarlane Misha Collins takes over from 2016 to 2019 necessitating his departure from supernatural early in this universe then he announces his resignation in 2019 leaving in the 2020 new years/Christmas special to be replaced by unknown comedienne Kathryn Hahn evoking a portrayal similar to Malick's who at this point is considered this universes definitive doctor alongside Tom Baker, Sylvester McCoy and Bradley Cooper. Also bc of her involvement with DW overlapping with the schedule Hahn dosen't get cast as Agatha Harkness in this Universe. And instead of Ben Schwartz as a companion its Jensen Ackles.
/10/21 retcon: i switched Misha out for Julian Richings and Hahn for Abigail Spencer.


Connoisseur of the Miscellaneous
Published by SLP
Nu Yawk
Here's the question I always want to ask whenever I see a pop culture AH: What if Doctor Who was never created at all?
McDiarmind season 18
1. Meglos ( Koo Stark as Sophie McDermott joins)
2. The Leisure Hive (different story than OTL written by Alan Dury)
3. The Doomsday Contract (written by Douglas Adams instead of John Lloyd)
4. The Nephilim (the unmade Psychonauts story with a different title)
5. Zaltys
6. Iliterations of I (written by Chris Bidmead)
7. The Pyramid Builders (return of the exxilons and a Mayan empire set episode)
8. Destruction Of Time ( McDiarmind regenerates into Una Stubbs)

Stubbs season 19
1. Renaissance Of the Daleks (Janet Fielding joins as Felicity Thompson)
2. Vayleon
3. The Exclusive Upgrade
4. The Servants of Doom (Geoffrey Palmer and the Autons Return)
5. The Kinda
6. Invasion Of The Plague Men
7. Wicked Sisters ( A Salem Witch Trials Pure Historical, Sophie Departs)
8. The Village Of Little Holdcombe (Seth Dies)

Stubbs season 20
1. Terror Of The Cybermen
2. Revenge Of The Macra
3. Warriors Of The Deep
4. Arc Of Infinity
5. Return To Vortis
6. Vengeance of the Master (Geoffery Palmer returns)
7. Attack Of The Exxilons
8. Island Of The Fendhal

special: The Five Doctors (Hartnell is recast into Geoffrey Bayldon)
Last edited: