• Hi Guest!

    The costs of running this forum are covered by Sea Lion Press. If you'd like to help support the company and the forum, visit patreon.com/sealionpress

Recent content by Strategos' Risk

  1. S

    More ironic Vichy-type puppet regimes

    The Stern Gang was willing to work with the Germans, perhaps they wouldn’t have to choose.
  2. S

    More ironic Vichy-type puppet regimes

    Very well put and comprehensive. Wang is perhaps an analogous figure in that his anti-colonialism and mistrust of Western imperialism allowed his leftism to coexist with Japanese collaborationism. As with the Belgian/French examples, it was a willingness to work with the currently winning party...
  3. S

    More ironic Vichy-type puppet regimes

    Why did it happen, is it like how so many U.S. ex-Trotskyists became neocons? To accept either worldview requires some acceptance of the same principles, e.g. the current order must be overthrown, mass movement by the people is good, and so on? Curious to consider fascists who became leftists...
  4. S

    More ironic Vichy-type puppet regimes

    Vichy France was led by some odd turncoats if you think about it. Petain was a national hero whose claim to fame was smiting Germans. Laval was a former Socialist - though admittedly, he perhaps he was as ambivalent about it as Mussolini was. Wang Jingwei and the Reorganized National Government...
  5. S

    Iraq without the Iraq War

    I'm idly wondering if Iranian adventurism since Iraq has been to their own detriment as much as American adventurism in Iraq and since has as well. Military operations, even covertly, ain't cheap, and in Syrian it hasn't been much covert. Have to wonder if absent those interventions, the...
  6. S

    Iraq without the Iraq War

    I don't think the Arab Spring would happen when it did OTL, if it does at all, because absent the chaos of the Iraq War, the Mideast's fortunes would be different. But if something like it did happen, one wonders if the Baathist government would go the way of Libya, or Syria. Okay, upon reading...
  7. S

    Best case for Zimbabwe post-WWII

    Maybe if Josiah Tongogara had lived he could have defeated Mugabe as a political rival.
  8. S

    Best case for Zimbabwe post-WWII

    Nkomo Georgist Utopia
  9. S

    Spain keeps Mexico

    The Brits held on to Canada all of this time, and the Portuguese made do with Brazil for quite some while. So it's not impossible. That said, the Spanish monarchy was ruled by a lot of dummies at this time, from what I understand, so I dunno how they could improve things. That said, maybe...
  10. S

    Spain keeps Mexico

    It would be funny if New Spain ended up the Canada to the rest of Latin America. Though Peru was the true royalist stronghold.
  11. S

    British Protectorate of the Republic of Formosa

    The POD might be the Battle of Baguashan going the other way, including if the leader of Japanese forces, Prince Kitashirakawa Yoshihisa was killed by battery fire before the battle.
  12. S

    What if Louis Napoleon felt compelled to go military adventurist like his uncle as soon as he took power?

    What if instead of imposing a foreign monarch he instead swooped in to negotiate a diplomatic end to the civil war, offered a royal figurehead in the spirit of whatever led the Mexicans to crown Iturbide in the first place, and sweetened the pot to Juárez and the Liberals by forgiving some of...
  13. S

    What if Louis Napoleon felt compelled to go military adventurist like his uncle as soon as he took power?

    Well, I generally like to see how far Bonapartist expansion can go, and I'll all for him playing it smart (which I don't know how historical that would be, but maybe he gets smart advisors), so absorbing Wallonia quickly while getting the blessing from everyone else seems the right approach, and...
  14. S

    What if Louis Napoleon felt compelled to go military adventurist like his uncle as soon as he took power?

    I think it might take some time between getting away with A/C and consolidating those gains before turning on the Germans to do B. I'm not sure how time-intensive it would take to accomplish those campaigns, though admittedly defeating Belgium and intervening in Italy doesn't take too long. It...
  15. S

    What if Louis Napoleon felt compelled to go military adventurist like his uncle as soon as he took power?

    What if he gradually pursued the more aggressive options, in the order of A, C (including taking Savoy and Nice), and B (while courting the Danes to serve as distraction from the north)?
Back
Top