A wiki-box is essentially a post in 'the story idea thread'. It's a shower thought.
Nothing more or nothing less than that.
This sort of insubstantial quality is why I almost never review online TLs on Fuldapocalypse. The "no online TL/uncommercialized fiction" rule started off as a way to avoid me getting sucked back into board drama (basically, most of the "Bad Fiction Spotlights" on my older blog were angry reactions to TLs on you-know-where-I specifically wanted to avoid them when making Fuldapocalypse). So I went with "only commercialized fiction" and it worked beautifully, especially after I widened the scope of the blog.
Much later, I felt I could do the occasional review of a TL (after all, there'd be room for one TL review alongside five reviews of commercialized cheap thrillers and four general opinion "essay" posts). I found, that with the exception of
New Deal Coalition Retained, I didn't want to. Part of it is not wanting to punch down at too easy a target (after all, the term "historical fanfiction" is a perfect description of a lot of internet AH, and I've seen the bad feelings/attitude that results from sneering at low-tier fanfic).
But I also found that they just weren't offering much material to work with. I don't know if it's to it's "credit" that NDCR did, but I could write a very detailed review on it that I think I just couldn't with most other TLs. Even the ones that started the WW3 interest in me to begin with just look insubstantial and come across as just "they're triple-xeroxed, bland knockoffs of Hackett/RSR/Bond. Except for the Red Dawn ones, which are that AND trying to stuff the square peg of a conventional invasion of the continental US into the round hole of detailed, exact rivet counting". That's two sentences. I tried to expand but it just didn't feel like I needed more than that to talk about them.
This is also present in lots of other fiction, including stuff that's enjoyable. I can enjoy
reading a formulaic-but-detailed "51% book", but it's very hard to review, and I felt a lot better once I no longer felt an obligation to review every single one of those that I read. But it went to new heights with online TLs. That, combined with me having tons of other stuff that
is reviewable in a fun way has turned me off from reviewing them. And since my blog is about having fun, it's something I'm OK with.