The 1783 Peace of Paris restored, on paper, Spanish control over West and East Florida but in actuality Spain had too many other priorities to enforce much control over a land mostly populated by natives americans, criminals, escaped slaves and political exiles and the land became a lawless anarchy.
Into this environment came various filibusters hoping to take control of the land and annex it to the United States. West Florida was lost to an American backed rebellion in 1810 and annexed to the USA, the Spanish supporting population of the Tangipahoa and Tchefuncte River regions were crushed by the Louisianian Milita and forced to flee into East Florida. In 1812 the USA attempted the same trick in East Florida but were forced to withdraw in disgrace lest they start a war with Spain while fighting the British at the same time.
The election of DeWitt Clinton in 1812 on an anti war, isolationist ticket however halted serious American attempts to control the region and allowed other factions to take advantage.
Leaders of the Free Republic of Florida (Unrecognized State)
Gregor MacGregor (1817)
Born in Scotland, MacGregor had left the British army in 1810 after a fight with a superior officer and joined the Venezuelan Revolutionary Army in 1812. However, history was to repeat itself as despite winning some notable victories for the rebels he fell out with General Piar and sailed off to Haiti in 1815. There he recruited soldiers for an attempt to take the fight to Spain elsewhere, landing in Amelia Island and declaring the Republic of Florida in 1817. The new republic was to encounter problems from the start, MacGregor had hoped for more support from the USA then he was to get and what American Filibusters he did recruit clashed with both his Haitian Freemen and with the smugglers and criminals of Amelia he hoped to win over. MacGregor, soon unable to pay or supply his troops, feared mutiny and sailed away after only three months leaving his second command in charge.
Reuben Kemper (1817)
Kemper had a long history of anti Spanish filibustering, he had attempted to declare West Florida independent in 1804 and was arrested in 1810 while attempting to cross into West Florida a second time during the successful rebellion. In 1812 he then joined a joint American-Mexican expedition that managed to, briefly, free Spanish Texas from Royal control. During that expedition the rebels had managed to gather an army made up of free blacks, american filibusters, spanish speaking rebels and native americans and meld then into one. Kemper saw it as his job to repeat the same feat in Florida, and he managed to beat off the only Spanish Attack on the Island, but without more supplies he was unable to follow that up by attacking the Spanish positions and so the situation seemed hopeless.
Jean Lafitte (1817-18)
Salvation for Kemper came in the form of three French privateers and smugglers, Louis-Michel Aury, Jean Lafitte and Pierre Lafitte, who having been driven out of Louisiana by US law enforcement were looking for a new base for their smuggling operations. Aury was at the the time, he claimed, working for the Mexican rebels and the Lafitte brothers were hoping for the same relationship with an independent Florida. The sorry state of Kemper's troops was something of a disappointment to the pirates but an agreement was quickly reached that saw Kemper recognise Lafitte as the President of the New Republic while Kemper took control of the armed forces, which reinforced with Aury's and Lafitte's men he used to drive the Spanish back to St Augustine and laid siege to Castillo de San Marcos. The ultimate aims of the Rebellion however, that is whether Florida, when free, should join Mexico or the USA were never truly resolved and this tension led the pro Mexican Aury to his next step.
MacGregor and Kemper had both relied on their Haitian freeman as foot soldiers, this was a time in which thousands of Haitians had fled the violence of the Haitian revolution to go abroad and were happy to look for opportunity elsewhere. In his little army, Lafitte had such notable Black Haitian soldiers as Joseph Savery, a resident of New Orleans who had moved there after collaborating with the French Army during the 1802 campaign, Joseph Courtois, who had been at a French military school fighting for the Republic when Napoleon had stripped away the rights of Black citizen in France and was thus prevented from leaving due to the ban on free movement, and Joseph's brother Sévère, who had arrived in 1818 from the Front lines in Venezuela. Shortly after Sévère's arrival, Aury sent the three men with 200 men to cross Florida and make common cause with the escaped and freed slaves that littered North Florida and fought constant skirmishes with American Militas. While this had obvious military benefits, it also had the Political benefit of pushing Florida closer to the abolitionist Mexican rebels and further from the slave owning American south.
When news of the expedition got out, there was outrage among Kemper's filibusters and there was a short and intense battle between the various gangs on Amelia Island which resulted in the death of Lafitte, the execution of four Americans, including Ruggles Hubbard, and Aury taking control.
Louis Michel Aury (1818)
Aury's problem was that having sent away his Haitian Freeman, the only sizeable army left in the rebel Republic belonged to Kemper who had reason to resent Aury's execution of several of his men. His problems got even worse when in the aftermath of the Death of his brother, Pierre Lafitte left Florida to return to Lousiana and took with him many of the brother's pirates. When Kemper and his second in command Jared Irwin, having taken St Augustine, returned to Fernandinha with his army and refused to obey Aury's orders, Aury fled and allowed Kemper once again to take control.
Reuben Kemper (1818-20)
The unwillingness to do anything about Florida as Spanish control there disintegrated and anarchy reigned lose on their southern borders was increasingly hurting President Clinton among the voters and his inaction spurred up increasingly desire for private action among the American South. In January 1819, a second lot of American filibusters led by John McIntosh, who had been a major figure during the failed 1812 filibustering attempt, arrived to join Kemper in Amelia Island which allowed the rebels to spread their control further across the Mainland. With St. Augustine fallen, the white population of Florida was almost all under the Republic's control and as of yet there was no sign of Spanish reinforcement, which meant that the Rebel campaign involved mainly bringing isolated white traders and settlers peacefully under the Republic's control, though there were also the first hostile encounters with Seminole Indians.
In late 1819, however a small Spanish Army landed in Florida. It was all that had been able to be sent of the ten battalions originally raised to fight for Spain in the New World, after several of those battalions had revolted under Rafael del Riego rather than be sent abroad. The 500 soldiers that were raised would do little good in Mexico or South America but it was hoped might be able to reclaim Florida at least.
The Spanish defeated the rebels in several pitched battles, severely wounding Kemper, and quickly laid siege to Castillo de San Amrcos. The Spanish had difficulty being supplied from Cuba and so the siege was only laxly enforced but the rebels had lost morale and the situation quickly fell into stalemate. Until, in early 1820, when Savery and the Courtois brothers returned with the Haitian Freedmen and their new allies.
Savery's mission had always been a fools errand. The Rebels maps of Florida were poor, and their supplies low. Savery was able to secure the support of one of the Spanish residents of Amelia as a guide but the Spanish trade and smuggling was a primarily sea based operation and the location of the Maroons were deep inland and a closely guarded secret. Moreover the major Maroon villages that were well known due to being coastal, such as Angola and Apalachicola, were on the western side of Florida and getting to them meant either following the Spanish forts or crossing the swamps. Savery attempted to do the latter but disease and lack of supplies thinned his troops badly and it is entirely possible the entire expedition would have failed had it not been for the lucky intervention of a village of Black Seminoles, who took in the Soldiers.
The Haitians arrived at a decisive moment of Seminole history. The various villages and tribes known as the Seminoles, including the escaped slaves who had joined them, were essentially independent but paid a loose tribute to the more powerful tribes. The principle chiefs of those more powerful tribes, such as Bolek and Kinache, were at that time in a conference to discuss the war on their northern border as they and their Creek allies skirmished with the US Army. Francis the Prophet, an ardent advocate of war against the white man and of native indian unity, had come to Florida to request full Seminole assistance for the Creek. Savery, seeing which way the wind was blowing, painted the existence of the Spanish, who as far as he knew still controlled St Augustine, as a potential dagger in the Seminole's back. Yes, the Spanish had always enjoyed decent relations with the Seminole but if Indians would fight for Indians why wouldn't white men fight for white men? But if the Seminole were to send with him a few warriors he could end that threat forever and establish his own maroon village there, which would happily fit into the same vassal/tributary relationship to the Seminole leadership that the existing Black Seminole villages did.
Kinache was unconvinced but Savery's vision of racial solidarity, that white men would always be untrustworthy and black men would always be loyal vassals, fitted neatly into Francis' talk of Indian unity. More over Bolek and many of the other young men saw a chance for plunder and glory in battling a much weaker enemy to the South. The broken bleeding army of Haitians that had entered the swamp would leave much larger and much better supplied.
Joseph Savery (1820-23)
The extent to which Savery and the Courtois brothers were idealists who were always in it to create a Free Black Republic rather than exiles and opportunists primarily looking for any way to make money who were happy to go along with the original filibuster plans is disputed. Certainly they seemed loyal enough to MacGregor and Kemper at the beginning of it. But with Kemper bleeding to death inside a besieged castle and Savery in control of the largest Army in East Florida, that attitude had changed.
Savery attacked the Spanish from the rear, forcing them to surrender after three days fighting, and then, when admitted into the Castle by Jared Irwin, quickly seized control of the besieged filibusters. Kemper had apparently died the week before Savery's army could get there and McIntosh had made himself unpopular with the Spanish residents meaning there was no real leadership to oppose him. That does not mean however, that Savery's accession was not contested. In 'the Second Haitian Massacre' some 100 white men, primarily followers of McIntosh, were executed for attempted mutiny.
News of this atrocity quickly reached the outraged ears of the American South and in 1821, President Monroe bowed to the inevitable and send word to Spain that since they had lost control of their territory to 'Negros, Natives and Criminals' the United States had to choice but to invade and annex Florida in order to bring it back into civilization.
This was a death blow for Savery's new Republic. If he had hoped for new men and supplies to arrive from either Mexico or Boyer's Haiti, who had just unified Hispaniola under his rule, he would be disappointed. Faced with an American invasion, albeit one manfully resisted by his allies among the Creek and Seminole, support dried up and St Augustine became increasingly isolated and changed hands yet again when the Americans captured it in 1822.
Savery and his closest supporters fled into the wilderness to continue a guerrila fight but a little over a year later, they were betrayed, captured and executed. The territory was not entirely pacified until another two decades later, but he was the last man to claim the title of President of Florida.