• Hi Guest!

    The costs of running this forum are covered by Sea Lion Press. If you'd like to help support the company and the forum, visit patreon.com/sealionpress

Alternate Athlete Performances

Coiler

Connoisseur of the Miscellaneous
Published by SLP
Location
Nu Yawk
Pronouns
He/Him
Just a question I'm curious about for sports alternate history.

What is the biggest difference in performance of an ATL athlete compared to their OTL self that doesn't involve injuries (be it avoiding a severe OTL injury or getting one when they didn't in real life) that you'd be willing to accept?
 
Just a question I'm curious about for sports alternate history.

What is the biggest difference in performance of an ATL athlete compared to their OTL self that doesn't involve injuries (be it avoiding a severe OTL injury or getting one when they didn't in real life) that you'd be willing to accept?
Basketball is pretty easy to screw around with - just prevent a player going cold (John Starks is a pretty obvious example, Knicks might have two NBA titles if he didn't brick every shot at the crucial moment) and vice versa, and then they suddenly can either become one of the greats or a laughing stock in a few short moments.
 
What about sportsmen who could have excelled in other sports?

The two who immediately come to my mind are Phil Neville and Joe Hart. But there must be countless others. The two mentioned were both very promising youth cricketers, who ended up choosing football when a decision was pressed. Andrew Flintoff is on record saying that Neville was keeping him out of the Lancashire youth side until he went full time with Man Utd, freeing up a space for Freddie. Hart made the call aged sixteen, after being loaned out from Man City to Shrewsbury Town. The first choice goalkeeper became injured, which meant Hart started getting serious chances of first team football. Despite his bowling prowess, it was likely to be at least five years or more before he had the chance of breaking through with Worcestershire, so football it was.

I once wrote a little vignette about the 2005 England-Australia test series, colloquially known as "Neville's Ashes".
 
Philip Neville: One of the illustrious Neville siblings, his elder brother Gary was captain of both Manchester United and England's national football teams, and Phil's twin sister Tracey an England Netball international. Not to be outdone, Philip decided against a life playing alongside his brother, pursuing his other passion: cricket. While Phil was a gifted footballer, by the age of fifteen, he had broken records by gaining entry into Lancashire's second XI, as well as captaining England's Under-15s. A long and successful career followed, for both Lancashire and England. A talented all-rounder, his medium-paced seam deliveries often managed to catch the new ball with a wicked reverse swing, confounding batsmen across the world; while his batting prowess saw Neville deployed at number five for England, a linchpin of the middle order. The highlight of Neville's career, of course, is the Test Series simply known as "Neville's Ashes". In one of the most widely followed cricket series in recent history, Britain stood entranced as England captain Michael Vaighan faced Ricky Ponting's Australians in a thrilling five game encounter. Recovering from a superb Australian performance in the First Test, England, led by their talisman Neville, fought back. An agonising draw in the Second Test was followed by a rain affected Third, in which Neville took the wicket of final batsman Brett Lee with only three balls left in his over, and the light fading fast. The last two days of the Fourth Test, in which Neville and his best friend and Lancashire team-mate Andrew Flintoff saved a collapsing top order to steady a severely wobbling England, was the innings that catapulted Neville from "Gary's little brother" to "England superstar". After Flintoff fell to Shane Warne, the spinner's 600th career wicket, Neville carried the tail order through the day, with partner Steve Harmison, of all people, scoring the winning runs. The fifth and final Test, with the country at a standstill, saw Neville take his tally of wickets up to twenty for the series, posting his second century of the campaign before it ended in a draw, with England as victors by two tests to one. This, the first Ashes victory for England since 1989, and the last to be shown live on terrestrial television, captured the public imagination like none since, and will always be known by the name of the sporting hero who brought the urn back home: Neville's Ashes.

Now retired from international cricket, Philip Neville still plays County Cricket for Lancashire, is a regular guest commentator on BBC Radio 4's Test Match Special, and an avid supporter of Bury Football Club.


AN: This was prompted by an interview with Flintoff, who claimed that Neville could have kept him out of both Lancashire and England's first teams, had he not chosen football instead. I didn't want to do that to Freddy, but Phil is now the star of the 2005 Ashes Series.
 
The obvious one that comes to mind is what if Scott Norwood didn't miss that field goal at the end of the Superbowl in 1990?

That could have changed quite a few things.

The other obvious NFL one is what if Tom Brady doesn't work out in relief of Drew Bledsoe in 2001?
 
What about sportsmen who could have excelled in other sports?

The first ones who come to mind for me are Charlie Ward (won the Heisman Trophy but had a successful pro career as a basketball player) and Dave Winfield (baseball player, played basketball in college effectively, and got selected in not just the baseball and basketball but also the NFL draft too).
 
Back
Top